Koppel J I, Pietroni R G
Occas Pap R Coll Gen Pract. 1991 Jun(51):1-19.
The need for higher professional education courses has been well established by young principals, medical educationalists and the Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP, 1985a, 1987 and 1990; Regional Advisers, 1989). In recent years there has been an increase in their development. However there is still a small number catering for a very small group of potential learners. These courses have often been seen as an extension of vocational training. Seven such courses were identified and evaluated during this project. The method and the results of the evaluation are presented. The development of higher professional education courses needs to be tailored to particular local needs and any central planning can be stifling. In our project there was often inadequate organizational and financial support available. The courses proved to be demanding for the participants in terms of time and required motivation. Despite this, attendance was good. Much of the content of the courses laid emphasis on practice management, human behaviour, and medicine and society, which reflected the perceived needs of both organizers and participants. Where formative evaluation of the courses was carried out, this appeared to have an important effect on course development. However fewer than 50% of the participants were involved to any extent in any planning of the courses, which is clearly contrary to the recognized principles of adult of self-directed learning (Brookfield, 1986). Despite this, participants as a whole appreciated the courses and the effect these had on their work, a large proportion reporting a significant change in cognitive and affective areas of learning. Recommendations are made for future organizers of higher professional education courses.
年轻校长、医学教育工作者以及皇家全科医师学院(RCGP,1985年a版、1987年版和1990年版;区域顾问,1989年)早已明确了对高等职业教育课程的需求。近年来,这类课程的发展有所增加。然而,仍有少数课程仅面向极少数潜在学习者。这些课程常被视为职业培训的延伸。在本项目中,确定并评估了七门此类课程。现将评估方法和结果呈现如下。高等职业教育课程的开发需要根据特定的当地需求进行调整,任何中央规划都可能具有抑制作用。在我们的项目中,往往缺乏足够的组织和资金支持。事实证明,这些课程对参与者的时间要求很高,且需要他们有学习动力。尽管如此,出勤率依然很高。课程的大部分内容都强调实践管理、人类行为以及医学与社会,这反映了组织者和参与者所察觉到的需求。在对课程进行形成性评估的地方,这似乎对课程开发产生了重要影响。然而,参与课程任何规划的参与者不到50%,这显然有悖于成人自主学习的公认原则(布鲁克菲尔德,1986年)。尽管如此,参与者总体上对课程及其对工作的影响表示赞赏,很大一部分人报告称在学习的认知和情感领域有显著变化。针对未来高等职业教育课程的组织者提出了建议。