Hsiao Janet Hui-wen, Shieh Danke X, Cottrell Garrison W
Department of Computer Science and Engineering, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA 92093-0404, USA.
J Cogn Neurosci. 2008 Dec;20(12):2298-307. doi: 10.1162/jocn.2008.20162.
Anatomical evidence shows that our visual field is initially split along the vertical midline and contralaterally projected to different hemispheres. It remains unclear at which processing stage the split information converges. In the current study, we applied the Double Filtering by Frequency (DFF) theory (Ivry & Robertson, 1998) to modeling the visual field split; the theory assumes a right-hemisphere/low-frequency bias. We compared three cognitive architectures with different timings of convergence and examined their cognitive plausibility to account for the left-side bias effect in face perception observed in human data. We show that the early convergence model failed to show the left-side bias effect. The modeling, hence, suggests that the convergence may take place at an intermediate or late stage, at least after information has been extracted/encoded separately in the two hemispheres, a fact that is often overlooked in computational modeling of cognitive processes. Comparative anatomical data suggest that this separate encoding process that results in differential frequency biases in the two hemispheres may be engaged from V1 up to the level of area V3a and V4v, and converge at least after the lateral occipital region. The left-side bias effect in our model was also observed in Greeble recognition; the modeling, hence, also provides testable predictions about whether the left-side bias effect may also be observed in (expertise-level) object recognition.
解剖学证据表明,我们的视野最初是沿着垂直中线分开的,并对侧投射到不同的半球。目前尚不清楚分开的信息在哪个处理阶段会汇聚。在当前的研究中,我们应用了频率双重过滤(DFF)理论(Ivry & Robertson,1998)来对视野分割进行建模;该理论假设存在右半球/低频偏向。我们比较了三种具有不同汇聚时间的认知架构,并检验了它们在解释人类数据中面部感知的左侧偏向效应方面的认知合理性。我们发现早期汇聚模型未能显示出左侧偏向效应。因此,该建模表明汇聚可能发生在中间或后期阶段,至少是在信息已经在两个半球中分别提取/编码之后,而这一事实在认知过程的计算建模中常常被忽视。比较解剖学数据表明,这种导致两个半球频率偏向不同的单独编码过程可能从V1一直持续到V3a和V4v区域的水平,并至少在枕叶外侧区域之后汇聚。我们的模型中的左侧偏向效应在 Greeble 识别中也被观察到;因此,该建模还提供了关于在(专业水平的)物体识别中是否也可能观察到左侧偏向效应的可测试预测。