Komada Tomohiro, Naganawa Shinji, Ogawa Hiroshi, Matsushima Masaya, Kubota Seiji, Kawai Hisashi, Fukatsu Hiroshi, Ikeda Mitsuru, Kawamura Minako, Sakurai Yasuo, Maruyama Katsuya
Department of Radiology, Nagoya University Graduate School of Medicine, Nagoya, Japan.
Magn Reson Med Sci. 2008;7(1):13-21. doi: 10.2463/mrms.7.13.
We evaluated the newly developed whole-brain, isotropic, 3-dimensional turbo spin-echo imaging with variable flip angle echo train (SPACE) for contrast-enhanced T(1)-weighted imaging in detecting brain metastases at 3 tesla (T). Twenty-two patients with suspected brain metastases underwent postcontrast study with SPACE, magnetization-prepared rapid gradient-echo (MP-RAGE), and 2-dimensional T(1)-weighted spin echo (2D-SE) imaging at 3T. We quantitatively compared SPACE, MP-RAGE, and 2D-SE images by using signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) for gray matter (GM) and white matter (WM) and contrast-to-noise ratios (CNRs) for GM-to-WM, lesion-to-GM, and lesion-to-WM. Two blinded radiologists evaluated the detection of brain metastases by segment-by-segment analysis and continuously-distributed test. The CNR between GM and WM was significantly higher on MP-RAGE images than on SPACE images (P<0.01). The CNRs for lesion-to-GM and lesion-to-WM were significantly higher on SPACE images than on MP-RAGE images (P<0.01). There was no significant difference in each sequence in detection of brain metastases by segment-by-segment analysis and the continuously-distributed test. However, in some cases, the lesions were easier to detect in SPACE images than in other sequences, and also the vascular signals, which sometimes mimic lesions in MP-RAGE and 2D-SE images, were suppressed in SPACE images. In detection of brain metastases at 3T magnetic resonance (MR) imaging, SPACE imaging may provide an effective, alternative approach to MP-RAGE imaging for 3D T(1)-weighted imaging.
我们评估了新开发的全脑、各向同性、三维可变翻转角回波链快速自旋回波成像(SPACE),用于在3特斯拉(T)场强下进行对比增强T1加权成像以检测脑转移瘤。22例疑似脑转移瘤患者在3T场强下接受了SPACE、磁化准备快速梯度回波(MP-RAGE)和二维T1加权自旋回波(2D-SE)成像的增强扫描。我们通过计算灰质(GM)和白质(WM)的信噪比(SNR)以及GM与WM、病变与GM、病变与WM的对比噪声比(CNR),对SPACE、MP-RAGE和2D-SE图像进行了定量比较。两名盲法放射科医生通过逐段分析和连续分布检验评估脑转移瘤的检出情况。MP-RAGE图像上GM与WM之间的CNR显著高于SPACE图像(P<0.01)。SPACE图像上病变与GM、病变与WM的CNR显著高于MP-RAGE图像(P<0.01)。在逐段分析和连续分布检验中,各序列在脑转移瘤检测方面无显著差异。然而,在某些情况下,SPACE图像中的病变比其他序列更容易检测到,而且在SPACE图像中,有时在MP-RAGE和2D-SE图像中会模拟病变的血管信号被抑制。在3T磁共振(MR)成像检测脑转移瘤时,对于三维T1加权成像,SPACE成像可能为MP-RAGE成像提供一种有效的替代方法。