Ndetei David M, Khasakhala Lincoln, Maru Hitesh, Pizzo Matteo, Mutiso Victoria, Ongecha-Owuor Francisca A, Kokonya Donald A
Africa Mental Health Foundation, Nairobi, Kenya.
Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 2008 Sep;43(9):736-42. doi: 10.1007/s00127-008-0360-y. Epub 2008 May 8.
Knowledge of types and co-morbidities of disorders seen in any facility is useful for clinical practice and planning for services.
To study the pattern of co-morbidities of and correlations between psychiatric disorders in in-patients of Mathari Hospital, the premier psychiatric hospital in Kenya.
Cross-sectional.
All the patients who were admitted at Mathari Hospital in June 2004 and were well enough to participate in the study were approached for informed consent. Trained psychiatric charge nurses interviewed them using the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV Axis I disorders Clinical Version (SCID-I). Information on their socio-demographic profiles and hospital diagnoses was extracted from their clinical notes using a structured format.
Six hundred and ninety-one patients participated in the study. Sixty-three percent were male. More than three quarters (78%) of the patients were aged between 21 and 45 years. More than half (59.5%) of the males and slightly less than half (49.4%) of the females were single. All the patients were predominantly of the Christian faith. Over 85% were dependents of another family member and the remainder were heads of households who supported their own families. Schizophrenia, bipolar I disorder, psychosis, substance use disorder and schizo-affective disorder were the most common hospital and differential diagnoses. Of the anxiety disorders, only three patients were under treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Nearly a quarter (24.6%) of the patients were currently admitted for a similar previous diagnosis. Schizophrenia was the most frequent DSM-IV (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders-fourth edition) diagnosis (51%), followed by bipolar I disorder (42.3%), substance use disorder (34.4%) and major depressive illness (24.6%). Suicidal features were common in the depressive group, with 14.7% of this group reporting a suicidal attempt. All DSM-IV anxiety disorders, including obsessive-compulsive disorders, were highly prevalent although, with the exception of three cases of PTSD, none of these anxiety disorders were diagnosed clinically. Traumatic events were reported in 33.3% of the patients. These were multiple and mainly violent events. Despite the multiplicity of these events, only 7.4% of the patients had a PTSD diagnosis in a previous admission while 4% were currently diagnosed with PTSD. The number of DSM-IV diagnoses was more than the total number of patients, suggesting co-morbidity, which was confirmed by significant 2-tailed correlation tests.
DSM-IV substance use disorders, major psychiatric disorders and anxiety disorders were prevalent and co-morbid. However, anxiety disorders were hardly diagnosed and therefore not managed. Suicidal symptoms were common. These results call for more inclusive clinical diagnostic practice. Standardized clinical practice using a diagnostic tool on routine basis will go a long way in ensuring that no DSM-IV diagnosis is missed. This will improve clinical management of patients and documentation.
了解任何医疗机构中所见到的疾病类型及其合并症,对于临床实践和服务规划都很有用。
研究肯尼亚首屈一指的精神病医院——马萨里医院住院患者中精神疾病的合并症模式及其相关性。
横断面研究。
2004年6月在马萨里医院住院且身体状况良好、能够参与研究的所有患者均被要求签署知情同意书。经过培训的精神科主管护士使用《精神疾病诊断与统计手册第四版》轴I障碍临床版结构化临床访谈(SCID-I)对他们进行访谈。使用结构化格式从他们的临床记录中提取有关其社会人口学特征和医院诊断的信息。
691名患者参与了研究。63%为男性。超过四分之三(78%)的患者年龄在21至45岁之间。超过一半(59.5%)的男性和略少于一半(49.4%)的女性为单身。所有患者主要为基督教信徒。超过85%是其他家庭成员的受抚养人,其余是供养自己家庭的户主。精神分裂症、双相I型障碍、精神病、物质使用障碍和分裂情感性障碍是最常见的医院诊断和鉴别诊断。在焦虑症中,只有3名患者因创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)正在接受治疗。近四分之一(24.6%)的患者目前因之前类似的诊断而入院。精神分裂症是最常见的《精神疾病诊断与统计手册第四版》(DSM-IV)诊断(51%),其次是双相I型障碍(42.3%)、物质使用障碍(34.4%)和重度抑郁症(24.6%)。自杀特征在抑郁症组中很常见,该组中有14.7%的患者报告有自杀未遂。所有DSM-IV焦虑症,包括强迫症,都非常普遍,不过,除了3例PTSD病例外,这些焦虑症均未得到临床诊断。33.3%的患者报告有创伤性事件。这些事件是多起且主要是暴力事件。尽管有这些多起事件,但只有7.4%的患者在之前入院时有PTSD诊断,而4%的患者目前被诊断为PTSD。DSM-IV诊断的数量超过了患者总数,表明存在合并症,这一点通过显著的双尾相关性检验得到了证实。
DSM-IV物质使用障碍、主要精神疾病和焦虑症普遍存在且合并存在。然而,焦虑症几乎未得到诊断,因此也未得到治疗。自杀症状很常见。这些结果呼吁采用更具包容性的临床诊断实践。在常规基础上使用诊断工具进行标准化临床实践,将在很大程度上确保不会遗漏任何DSM-IV诊断。这将改善患者的临床管理和记录。