Ali Moazzam, Ahmed Khawaja Masuood, Kuroiwa Chushi
Department of Health Policy and Planning, Institute of International Health, Graduate School of Medicine, The University of Tokyo, Japan.
Eur J Contracept Reprod Health Care. 2008 Jun;13(2):201-7. doi: 10.1080/13625180701877712.
This paper describes an approach to maternal mortality reduction in Pakistan that uses UN emergency obstetric care (EmOC) process indicators to examine if public health care centres in Pakistan's Punjab province comply with minimum recommendations for basic and comprehensive services.
In a cross sectional study in September 2003, through random sampling at area and health-facility levels from 30% of districts in Punjab province (n = 11/34 districts), all public health facilities providing EmOC were included (n = 120). Facility data were used for analysis.
No district in Punjab met the minimum standards laid down by the UN for providing EmOC services. The number of facilities providing basic and comprehensive EmOC services fell far short of recommended levels. Only 4.7% of women with complications attended hospitals. Caesarean section was carried out in only 0.4% of births. The case fatality rate was hard to accurately calculate due to poor record keeping and data quality.
The study may be taken as a baseline for developing and improving the standards of services in Punjab province. It is vital to upgrade existing basic EmOC facilities and to ensure that staff skills be improved, facilities be better equipped in critical areas, and record keeping be improved. Hence to reduce maternal mortality, facilities for EmOC must exist, be accessible, offer quality services, and be utilized by patients with complications.
本文介绍了巴基斯坦降低孕产妇死亡率的一种方法,该方法利用联合国紧急产科护理(EmOC)过程指标来检查巴基斯坦旁遮普省的公共卫生保健中心是否符合基本和综合服务的最低建议。
在2003年9月的一项横断面研究中,通过在旁遮普省30%的地区(n = 11/34个区)进行地区和卫生设施层面的随机抽样,纳入了所有提供EmOC的公共卫生设施(n = 120)。设施数据用于分析。
旁遮普省没有一个区达到联合国规定的提供EmOC服务的最低标准。提供基本和综合EmOC服务的设施数量远远低于建议水平。只有4.7%的并发症妇女前往医院就诊。剖宫产仅占分娩总数的0.4%。由于记录保存和数据质量较差,难以准确计算病死率。
该研究可作为旁遮普省制定和提高服务标准的基线。升级现有的基本EmOC设施、确保提高工作人员技能、在关键领域更好地配备设施以及改善记录保存至关重要。因此,为降低孕产妇死亡率,必须有EmOC设施,这些设施要易于获得、提供优质服务,并被有并发症的患者所利用。