McGuire James
Division of Clinical Psychology, School of Population, Community and Behavioural Sciences, University of Liverpool, Whelan Building, Liverpool L69 3GB, UK.
Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2008 Aug 12;363(1503):2577-97. doi: 10.1098/rstb.2008.0035.
This paper addresses the question of whether individual violence can be reduced in frequency or severity, if so to what extent and by which methods. It opens with a brief overview of the nature of personal violence and discussion of some key definitional and methodological problems. However, its principal focus is on the findings obtained from a series of meta-analytic reviews of structured programmes for adolescents and adults who have shown repeated aggression or been convicted of personal violence, drawing together the results of studies conducted in prison, probation, youth justice and allied services. Additional results are considered from a systematic review of studies of violence prevention among offenders with mental disorders. This incorporates the preliminary findings of a meta-analysis of controlled trials of psychosocial interventions with that population. Overall, it is concluded that there is sufficient evidence currently available to substantiate the claim that personal violence can be reduced by psychosocial interventions, but that much more research is required to delineate the parameters of effectiveness in this context. Proposals are made for future investigations with reference to the theoretical understanding of causal relationships and the design of experimental trials.
本文探讨了个人暴力行为的发生频率或严重程度是否能够降低,如果可以,能降低到何种程度以及通过何种方法降低。文章开篇简要概述了个人暴力的性质,并讨论了一些关键的定义和方法问题。然而,其主要重点是从一系列对青少年和成年人的结构化项目进行的元分析综述中获得的结果,这些青少年和成年人表现出反复攻击行为或因个人暴力被定罪,综合了在监狱、缓刑、青少年司法及相关服务机构开展的研究结果。还考虑了对患有精神障碍的罪犯预防暴力行为研究的系统综述的额外结果。这纳入了对该人群心理社会干预对照试验的元分析的初步结果。总体而言,得出的结论是,目前有足够的证据证实通过心理社会干预可以减少个人暴力行为的说法,但在此背景下,还需要更多的研究来界定有效性的参数。针对未来的调查提出了建议,涉及对因果关系的理论理解和实验试验的设计。