Abend Nicholas S, Licht Daniel J
Division of Neurology, The Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, Department of Neurology, The University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Pediatr Crit Care Med. 2008 Jan;9(1):32-9. doi: 10.1097/01.PCC.0000288714.61037.56.
Hypoxic ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) is common in children, and providing accurate and timely prognostic information is important in determining the appropriate level of care. While practice parameters are available for prognostication in adults, similar reviews are not available for children. This article reviews the current evidence in domains used to provide prognostic information in children with coma due to HIE. These include historical features of the event; physical exam signs; neurophysiologic studies, such as electroencephalogram and evoked potentials; and neuroimaging.
A literature search of MEDLINE was performed using the search terms HIE and prognosis cross-referenced in series with specific domains used to provide prognostic information, including physical examination, electroencephalogram, evoked potentials, neuroimaging, and magnetic resonance imaging. The results of these searches were scanned by the authors to identify articles pertaining to children (nonneonates). Further literature was identified from the reference lists of the literature identified by MEDLINE search. Clinical, preclinical, and review articles were identified that were related to the current understanding of prognosis in pediatric HIE. Only literature in English was reviewed.
When performed at least 24 hrs after the inciting event, abnormal exam signs (pupil reactivity and motor response), absent N20 waves bilaterally on somatosensory evoked potentials, electrocerebral silence or burst suppression patterns on electroencephalogram (not due to metabolic or medication etiology), and abnormal magnetic resonance imaging with diffusion restriction in the cortex and basal ganglia are each highly predictive of poor outcome. Combining these modalities improves the overall predictive value.
All testing provides the best prognostic information several days after hypoxic-ischemic injury, and often multiple tests are required to improve prognostic ability and rule out potentially confounding conditions. Thus, when decisions can be postponed several days, neurologic consultation and testing can provide the best prognostic information to families.
缺氧缺血性脑病(HIE)在儿童中很常见,提供准确及时的预后信息对于确定适当的护理水平很重要。虽然有针对成人预后的实践参数,但尚无针对儿童的类似综述。本文回顾了用于为HIE所致昏迷儿童提供预后信息的各领域的现有证据。这些领域包括事件的病史特征;体格检查体征;神经生理学研究,如脑电图和诱发电位;以及神经影像学检查。
使用搜索词“HIE”和“预后”,并与用于提供预后信息的特定领域(包括体格检查、脑电图、诱发电位、神经影像学和磁共振成像)进行交叉串联检索MEDLINE数据库。作者浏览了这些检索结果,以识别与儿童(非新生儿)相关的文章。从MEDLINE检索所识别文献的参考文献列表中进一步确定了相关文献。识别出了与目前对小儿HIE预后理解相关的临床、临床前和综述文章。仅对英文文献进行了综述。
在诱发事件发生至少24小时后进行检查时,异常的检查体征(瞳孔反应和运动反应)、体感诱发电位双侧N20波缺失、脑电图出现脑电静息或爆发抑制模式(非代谢或药物病因所致)以及皮质和基底节区有弥散受限的异常磁共振成像,均高度提示预后不良。综合这些检查方法可提高总体预测价值。
所有检查在缺氧缺血性损伤数天后能提供最佳预后信息,且通常需要多项检查来提高预后判断能力并排除潜在的混杂情况。因此,当决策可以推迟数天时,神经科会诊和检查可为家属提供最佳预后信息。