Ahmed Alaa A, Wolpert Daniel M, Flanagan J Randall
Computational and Biological Learning Lab, Department of Engineering, University of Cambridge, Cambridge CB2 1PZ, United Kingdom.
Department of Psychology and Centre for Neuroscience Studies, Queen's University, Kingston, Ontario K7L 3N6, Canada.
Curr Biol. 2008 May 20;18(10):763-768. doi: 10.1016/j.cub.2008.04.061.
To manipulate an object skillfully, the brain must learn its dynamics, specifying the mapping between applied force and motion. A fundamental issue in sensorimotor control is whether such dynamics are represented in an extrinsic frame of reference tied to the object or an intrinsic frame of reference linked to the arm. Although previous studies have suggested that objects are represented in arm-centered coordinates [1-6], all of these studies have used objects with unusual and complex dynamics. Thus, it is not known how objects with natural dynamics are represented. Here we show that objects with simple (or familiar) dynamics and those with complex (or unfamiliar) dynamics are represented in object- and arm-centered coordinates, respectively. We also show that objects with simple dynamics are represented with an intermediate coordinate frame when vision of the object is removed. These results indicate that object dynamics can be flexibly represented in different coordinate frames by the brain. We suggest that with experience, the representation of the dynamics of a manipulated object may shift from a coordinate frame tied to the arm toward one that is linked to the object. The additional complexity required to represent dynamics in object-centered coordinates would be economical for familiar objects because such a representation allows object use regardless of the orientation of the object in hand.
要熟练地操纵一个物体,大脑必须了解其动力学特性,即确定施加的力与运动之间的映射关系。感觉运动控制中的一个基本问题是,这种动力学特性是在与物体相关的外在参考系中表示,还是在与手臂相关的内在参考系中表示。尽管先前的研究表明物体是以手臂为中心的坐标来表示的[1-6],但所有这些研究都使用了具有异常和复杂动力学特性的物体。因此,尚不清楚具有自然动力学特性的物体是如何被表示的。在这里,我们表明,具有简单(或熟悉)动力学特性的物体和具有复杂(或不熟悉)动力学特性的物体分别以物体为中心和以手臂为中心的坐标来表示。我们还表明,当物体的视觉信息被去除时,具有简单动力学特性的物体是以一个中间坐标系来表示的。这些结果表明,大脑可以在不同的坐标系中灵活地表示物体的动力学特性。我们认为,随着经验的积累,被操纵物体动力学特性的表示可能会从与手臂相关的坐标系转向与物体相关的坐标系。对于熟悉的物体,在以物体为中心的坐标系中表示动力学特性所需的额外复杂性是经济的,因为这种表示允许无论手中物体的方向如何都能使用该物体。