Lin Chao-Cheng, Wang Ying-Chieh, Chen Jen-Yeu, Liou Ying-Jay, Bai Ya-Mei, Lai I-Ching, Chen Tzu-Ting, Chiu Hung-Wen, Li Yu-Chuan
Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences, College of Medicine, Taipei Medical University, Taiwan.
Comput Methods Programs Biomed. 2008 Aug;91(2):91-9. doi: 10.1016/j.cmpb.2008.02.004. Epub 2008 May 27.
Although one third to one half of refractory schizophrenic patients responds to clozapine, however, there are few evidences currently that could predict clozapine response before the use of the medication. The present study aimed to train and validate artificial neural networks (ANN), using clinical and pharmacogenetic data, to predict clozapine response in schizophrenic patients. Five pharmacogenetic variables and five clinical variables were collated from 93 schizophrenic patients taking clozapine, including 26 responders. ANN analysis was carried out by training the network with data from 75% of cases and subsequently testing with data from 25% of unseen cases to determine the optimal ANN architecture. Then the leave-one-out method was used to examine the generalization of the models. The optimal ANN architecture was found to be a standard feed-forward, fully-connected, back-propagation multilayer perceptron. The overall accuracy rate of ANN was 83.3%, which is higher than that of logistic regression (LR) (70.8%). By using the area under the receiver operating characteristics curve as a measure of performance, the ANN outperformed the LR (0.821+/-0.054 versus 0.579+/-0.068; p<0.001). The ANN with only genetic variables outperformed the ANN with only clinical variables (0.805+/-0.056 versus 0.647+/-0.066; p=0.046). The gene polymorphisms should play an important role in the prediction. Further validation of ANN analysis is likely to provide decision support for predicting individual response.
虽然三分之一到二分之一的难治性精神分裂症患者对氯氮平有反应,然而,目前几乎没有证据能够在使用该药物之前预测氯氮平的反应。本研究旨在利用临床和药物遗传学数据训练并验证人工神经网络(ANN),以预测精神分裂症患者对氯氮平的反应。从93名服用氯氮平的精神分裂症患者(包括26名有反应者)中整理出5个药物遗传学变量和5个临床变量。通过用75%的病例数据训练网络,随后用25%的未见过的病例数据进行测试来确定最佳的ANN结构,从而进行ANN分析。然后采用留一法来检验模型的泛化能力。发现最佳的ANN结构是一个标准的前馈、全连接、反向传播多层感知器。ANN的总体准确率为83.3%,高于逻辑回归(LR)(70.8%)。以受试者工作特征曲线下面积作为性能指标,ANN的表现优于LR(0.821±0.054对0.579±0.068;p<0.001)。仅包含遗传变量的ANN优于仅包含临床变量的ANN(0.805±0.056对0.647±0.066;p=0.046)。基因多态性在预测中应发挥重要作用。ANN分析的进一步验证可能会为预测个体反应提供决策支持。