Thornton Lisa M, Carson William E, Shapiro Charles L, Farrar William B, Andersen Barbara L
Department of Psychology, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 43210, USA.
Cancer. 2008 Aug 1;113(3):638-47. doi: 10.1002/cncr.23589.
There are few patient-reported data regarding quality of life after taxane-based adjuvant chemotherapy and none regarding mental health outcomes.
This was a naturalistic, longitudinal study that used a case-control design. Data were derived from a randomized clinical trial in patients who had stage II/III breast cancer (N = 227). Paclitaxel (Taxol) was approved for use midway during the accrual period (1994-1999). Patients who received taxanes as part of their adjuvant chemotherapy (the taxane group; n = 55) were matched with patients receiving regimens without taxanes (the no-taxane group; n = 83) on trial arm, lymph node status, surgery type, menopausal status, and partner status. Mixed-effects models tested for group differences in nurse evaluations of patients' symptoms and Karnofsky performance status and in patient-reported quality of life (the 36-item Medical Outcomes Study Short Form) and emotional distress (Profile of Mood States; Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression scale).
As expected, patients in the taxane group experienced significantly higher rates of selected toxicities, including arthralgia/myalgia (45% vs 26%) and ataxia (20% vs 5%). Patients in the taxane group also had significantly worse emotional distress and mental quality of life throughout adjuvant treatment. Rates of probable clinical depression also were high. In contrast, these outcomes were improving for patients in the no-taxane group (all P < .023). Emotional recovery for patients in the taxane group required 2 years on average versus 6 to 12 months for patients in the no-taxane group. During Years 3 through 5, the groups had similar outcomes.
These data suggested that taxane-based chemotherapies confer risk for significant psychological symptoms. Depression, in particular, should be monitored.
关于紫杉烷类辅助化疗后的生活质量,患者报告的数据很少,关于心理健康结果的数据则没有。
这是一项采用病例对照设计的自然主义纵向研究。数据来自一项针对II/III期乳腺癌患者的随机临床试验(N = 227)。紫杉醇(泰素)在入组期间(1994 - 1999年)中途获批使用。接受紫杉烷类作为辅助化疗一部分的患者(紫杉烷组;n = 55)与接受不含紫杉烷方案的患者(非紫杉烷组;n = 83)在试验组、淋巴结状态、手术类型、绝经状态和伴侣状态方面进行匹配。混合效应模型测试了护士对患者症状和卡氏功能状态评估、患者报告的生活质量(36项医学结局研究简表)以及情绪困扰(情绪状态剖面图;流行病学研究中心抑郁量表)方面的组间差异。
正如预期的那样,紫杉烷组患者出现特定毒性的发生率显著更高,包括关节痛/肌痛(45%对26%)和共济失调(20%对5%)。在整个辅助治疗期间,紫杉烷组患者的情绪困扰和心理生活质量也显著更差。可能的临床抑郁症发生率也很高。相比之下,非紫杉烷组患者的这些结局在改善(所有P < .023)。紫杉烷组患者的情绪恢复平均需要2年,而非紫杉烷组患者需要6至12个月。在第3年至第5年期间,两组的结局相似。
这些数据表明,基于紫杉烷的化疗会带来出现显著心理症状的风险。尤其应监测抑郁症。