Stein Dan J, Pedersen Ron, Rothbaum Barbara O, Baldwin David S, Ahmed Saeeduddin, Musgnung Jeff, Davidson Jonathan
University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa.
Int J Neuropsychopharmacol. 2009 Feb;12(1):23-31. doi: 10.1017/S1461145708008961. Epub 2008 Jun 11.
This pooled analysis of data from two randomized, placebo-controlled trials of venlafaxine extended release (ER) assessed onset of activity and time to response on the 17 symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) listed in DSM-IV and measured by the 17-item Clinician-Administered PTSD Scale (CAPS-SX17). The intent-to-treat (ITT) population comprised 687 patients (placebo, n=347; venlafaxine ER, n=340). Significant (p<0.05) separation between venlafaxine ER and placebo was observed on most CAPS-SX17 items, with earliest onset of activity and response (week 2) on items 5 (physiological reactivity on exposure to cues) and 14 (irritability or anger outbursts), and (week 4) items 1 (intrusive recollections) and 4 (psychological distress at exposure to cues). Onset of activity and response occurred later (generally, weeks 6-8) on items 9 (diminished interest/participation in activities), 10 (detachment or estrangement), 11 (restricted range of affect), 12 (sense of foreshortened future), all associated with numbing, 15 (difficulty concentrating), 16 (hypervigilance), 17 (exaggerated startle response), associated with hyperarousal, and 6 (avoidance of thoughts/feelings or conversations). Significant differences between venlafaxine ER and placebo were largely absent throughout the treatment period and at the primary week-12 end-point for items 2 (distressing dreams), 7 (avoidance of activities, places or people), 8 (inability to recall important aspect of trauma) and 13 (difficulty falling/staying asleep). These results indicate that symptoms of physiological reactivity and psychological distress in response to cues, and irritability/anger outbursts show early and robust improvement with venlafaxine ER treatment, while symptoms of numbing and hyperarousal take longer. The early and persistent effect of venlafaxine ER over placebo on anger/irritability is noteworthy in view of the clinical significance of these symptoms in PTSD.
本汇总分析来自两项关于文拉法辛缓释剂(ER)的随机、安慰剂对照试验的数据,评估了《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》第四版(DSM-IV)中列出的创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的17种症状的起效时间和达到反应的时间,并通过17项临床医生管理的PTSD量表(CAPS-SX17)进行测量。意向性治疗(ITT)人群包括687名患者(安慰剂组,n = 347;文拉法辛ER组,n = 340)。在大多数CAPS-SX17项目上观察到文拉法辛ER与安慰剂之间有显著(p<0.05)差异,在第5项(暴露于线索时的生理反应性)和第14项(易怒或愤怒爆发)上最早出现起效和反应(第2周),以及在第1项(侵入性回忆)和第4项(暴露于线索时的心理困扰)上(第4周)出现起效和反应。在第9项(对活动的兴趣/参与减少)、第10项(分离或疏远)、第11项(情感范围受限)、第12项(对未来的预期缩短感)(均与麻木有关)、第15项(注意力不集中)、第16项(过度警觉)、第17项(夸张的惊吓反应)(与过度觉醒有关)以及第6项(避免想法/感受或对话)上,起效和反应出现得较晚(一般在第6 - 8周)。在整个治疗期间以及在第12周主要终点时,文拉法辛ER与安慰剂在第2项(痛苦的梦境)、第7项(避免活动、场所或人)、第8项(无法回忆创伤的重要方面)和第13项(入睡/保持睡眠困难)上基本没有显著差异。这些结果表明,文拉法辛ER治疗能使暴露于线索时的生理反应性和心理困扰症状以及易怒/愤怒爆发症状早期且显著改善,而麻木和过度觉醒症状则需要更长时间。鉴于这些症状在PTSD中的临床意义,文拉法辛ER相对于安慰剂在愤怒/易怒方面的早期和持续效果值得关注。