Chabrol H, Mabila J D, Chauchard E
Centre d'études et de recherches en psychopathologie, université de Toulouse-Le Mirail, France.
Encephale. 2008 Jun;34(3):270-3. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2007.04.002. Epub 2007 Oct 24.
The aim of the study was to evaluate the relative contributions of cannabis use and depressive symptoms in the prediction of suicidal ideation.
A random sample of 491 high-school students from the department of Haute-Garonne, France (290 girls, mean age=16.6+/-1.4; 201 boys, mean age=17.3 years+/-1.6) completed a questionnaire assessing cannabis use, the CES-D (center for epidemiological studies-depression scale) completed by the three-item sub-scale measuring suicidal ideation proposed by Garrison et al. (J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 30 (1991) 636-641).
In the total sample, 15% of girls (n=44) and 23% of boys (n=46) reported having used cannabis at least once a month during the last three months. The mean CES-D score for girls was significantly higher than for boys (20.6+/-11 versus 18.4+/-10.9, t=2.4, p=0.01). According to the cut-off score of 24, 22% of boys and 36% of girls exhibited a moderate to severe depressive symptomatology (p=0.02). The mean suicidal ideation score was not significantly higher in girls than in boys (1.3+/-2 versus 0.95+/-1.9, t=1.7, p=0.10). At least, the occasional wish to kill oneself was reported by 17% of boys and 20% of girls (p=0.40). The contribution of cannabis use and depressive symptomatology in the prediction of suicidal ideation were tested with a hierarchical multiple regression analysis, to determine whether cannabis use improved prediction of suicidal ideation beyond that afforded by CES-D scores. In the first step, including age and sex as covariates, the model accounted for a significant and important part of the variance of suicidal ideation (41%). Age and sex were not significant predictors. The second step, with cannabis use added to the prediction of suicidal ideation, afforded an increase of 1% in predictable variance. Cannabis use (beta=0.08, t=2.2, p=0.03) was significantly but weakly related to suicidal ideation, while depressive symptoms (beta=0.63, t=17.8, p<0.001) remained the main predictor. In a second regression analysis conducted among cannabis users, frequency of use was almost a significant predictor (beta=0.11, t=1.84, p=0.07).
This result suggests an association between suicidal ideation, depressive symptoms and cannabis use in adolescents. Cannabis use appeared to be an independent predictor of suicidal ideation after controlling for depressive symptoms. However, the increment of variance accounted for by cannabis use was small. This suggests that cannabis use contributes to suicidal ideation independently from depressive symptoms, but weakly. A limitation to the study was the absence of control for other potential confounding variables. The association between cannabis use and suicidal ideation may be linked to common risk factors such as borderline personality disorder traits, sociodemographic and family factors. In this study, cannabis use does not appear as an important risk factor for suicidal ideation in adolescents.
本研究旨在评估大麻使用和抑郁症状在预测自杀意念方面的相对作用。
从法国上加龙省随机抽取491名高中生(290名女生,平均年龄 = 16.6 ± 1.4岁;201名男生,平均年龄 = 17.3岁 ± 1.6岁),他们完成了一份评估大麻使用情况的问卷,以及由加里森等人(《美国儿童与青少年精神病学杂志》30 (1991) 636 - 641)提出的用三项子量表测量自杀意念的流行病学研究中心抑郁量表(CES - D)。
在总样本中,15%的女生(n = 44)和23%的男生(n = 46)报告在过去三个月中每月至少使用一次大麻。女生的CES - D平均得分显著高于男生(20.6 ± 11对18.4 ± 10.9,t = 2.4,p = 0.01)。根据24分的临界值,22%的男生和36%的女生表现出中度至重度抑郁症状(p = 0.02)。女生的自杀意念平均得分并不显著高于男生(1.3 ± 2对0.95 ± 1.9,t = 1.7,p = 0.10)。至少,17%的男生和20%的女生报告有偶尔自杀的念头(p = 0.40)。采用分层多元回归分析来检验大麻使用和抑郁症状在预测自杀意念中的作用,以确定大麻使用是否能在CES - D得分之外提高对自杀意念的预测能力。第一步,将年龄和性别作为协变量纳入,该模型解释了自杀意念变异的一个显著且重要的部分(41%)。年龄和性别不是显著的预测因素。第二步,将大麻使用纳入自杀意念的预测模型后,可预测变异增加了1%。大麻使用(β = 0.08,t = 2.2,p = 0.03)与自杀意念显著但微弱相关,而抑郁症状(β = 0.63,t = 17.8,p < 0.001)仍然是主要预测因素。在对大麻使用者进行的第二次回归分析中,使用频率几乎是一个显著的预测因素(β = 0.11,t = 1.84,p = 0.07)。
该结果表明青少年的自杀意念、抑郁症状和大麻使用之间存在关联。在控制抑郁症状后,大麻使用似乎是自杀意念的一个独立预测因素。然而,大麻使用所解释的变异增量很小。这表明大麻使用独立于抑郁症状对自杀意念有影响,但作用较弱。本研究的一个局限性是未对其他潜在的混杂变量进行控制。大麻使用与自杀意念之间的关联可能与诸如边缘型人格障碍特质、社会人口学和家庭因素等共同风险因素有关。在本研究中,大麻使用似乎不是青少年自杀意念的一个重要风险因素。