Rocklöv Joacim, Forsberg Bertil
Occupational & Environmental Medicine, Department of Public Health and Clinical Medicine, Umeå University, Umeå, Sweden.
Scand J Public Health. 2008 Jul;36(5):516-23. doi: 10.1177/1403494807088458. Epub 2008 Jun 20.
To describe seasonal patterns of natural mortality in Stockholm as well as the temperature-mortality relationship and the lag structure for effects of high and low temperatures; to describe the impact of high temperatures on cardiovascular and respiratory mortality, and the general effect of high temperatures in different age groups; and to investigate whether there is any indication of an additional heatwave or cold spell effect.
Generalized additive Poisson regression models were fitted to mortality and temperature data from Stockholm from the period 1998-2003, controlling for influenza, season, time trends, week day, and holidays.
The mortality in Stockholm followed a seasonal pattern, with a peak in the winter season. The ;;optimal temperature'' was around 11-12 degrees C. Above this temperature, the cumulative general relative risk (RR) corresponded to a 1.4% (95% confidence interval (CI)=0.8-2.0) increase per degrees C, and below this temperature the cumulative RR corresponded to a 0.7% (95% CI=0.5-0.9) decrease per degrees C. Age-specific RRS were estimated above the threshold for age <65 years, age 65-74 years, and age >74 years, with estimated increases of 0.5% (not significant), 1.5% (not significant) and 1.6% (95% CI=0.9-2.3) per degrees C, respectively. The RRs for cardiovascular and respiratory causes were studied above the breakpoint, and estimated to be 1.1% (95% CI=0.3-2.0) and 4.3% (95% CI=2.2-6.5) per degrees C, respectively. The lag structures from moving averages and polynomial distributed lag models coincided with a rather direct effect during summer (lag 0 and 1) and a more prolonged effect during winter, covering about a week. The inclusion of an indicator of heatwaves added an increase in daily mortality of 3.1-7.7%, depending on the threshold.
These results show that the predicted increase in heat events must also be taken seriously in Scandinavia, whatever the extent of the decreasing cold related mortality. The relative risks associated with heat and heatwaves seem stronger than the cold effects and thus a larger public health threat, since northern populations have not yet adapted to heat as have been done over a long time for the cold periods. The pressure on the healthcare sector will probably increase in the warm season, periodically it may become even greater than the pressure due to cold weather, which will be a new phenomenon for the healthcare sector to cope with. We need to be prepared for these kind of events by developing adaptation and education strategies to handle the consequences that a warmer climate will have for public health and the healthcare sector.
描述斯德哥尔摩自然死亡率的季节性模式、温度与死亡率的关系以及高温和低温影响的滞后结构;描述高温对心血管和呼吸系统死亡率的影响以及不同年龄组中高温的总体影响;并调查是否有额外的热浪或寒潮效应迹象。
对1998 - 2003年期间斯德哥尔摩的死亡率和温度数据拟合广义相加泊松回归模型,控制流感、季节、时间趋势、工作日和节假日等因素。
斯德哥尔摩的死亡率呈现季节性模式,冬季达到峰值。“最佳温度”约为11 - 12摄氏度。高于此温度,累积总体相对风险(RR)相当于每升高1摄氏度增加1.4%(95%置信区间(CI)=0.8 - 2.0),低于此温度,累积RR相当于每降低1摄氏度减少0.7%(95% CI = 0.5 - 0.9)。针对年龄<65岁、65 - 74岁和>74岁的年龄组,在阈值以上估计了特定年龄的RR,每升高1摄氏度估计增加分别为0.5%(不显著)、1.5%(不显著)和1.6%(95% CI = 0.9 - 2.3)。对心血管和呼吸系统病因的RR在断点以上进行了研究,估计分别为每升高1摄氏度1.1%(95% CI = 0.3 - 2.0)和4.3%(95% CI = 2.2 - 6.5)。移动平均和多项式分布滞后模型的滞后结构在夏季(滞后0和1)呈现相当直接的效应,而在冬季效应持续时间更长,约为一周。纳入热浪指标后,根据阈值不同,每日死亡率增加3.1 - 7.7%。
这些结果表明,无论与寒冷相关的死亡率下降程度如何,斯堪的纳维亚地区预测的热事件增加也必须得到认真对待。与高温和热浪相关的相对风险似乎比寒冷效应更强,因此对公众健康构成更大威胁,因为北方人群尚未像长期适应寒冷时期那样适应高温。温暖季节医疗保健部门的压力可能会增加,周期性地甚至可能大于寒冷天气带来的压力,这将是医疗保健部门需要应对的新现象。我们需要通过制定适应和教育策略来应对气候变暖对公众健康和医疗保健部门造成的后果,为这类事件做好准备。