Kolotkin Ronette L, Crosby Ross D, Gress Richard E, Hunt Steven C, Engel Scott G, Adams Ted D
Obesity and Quality of Life Consulting, Durham, NC 27707, USA.
Surg Obes Relat Dis. 2008 Sep-Oct;4(5):651-8; discussion 658-9. doi: 10.1016/j.soard.2008.04.012. Epub 2008 Jun 30.
The aim of this study was to examine the differences between male and female bariatric surgery candidates with respect to health-related quality of life (HRQOL), health, sociodemographic variables, and interactions among these variables in a bariatric surgery practice in the United States. Women seek bariatric surgery 5 times more often than men. Research on gender differences in HRQOL is limited, and the results are conflicting.
A total of 794 surgery candidates (mean age 42.2 y; body mass index 46.9 kg/m2; 84.8% women) completed both a weight-related (Impact of Weight on Quality of Life-Lite questionnaire) and a generic (Medical Outcomes Study Short-Form-36) measure of HRQOL. Health was evaluated by questionnaire and clinical interviews.
Compared to men, women reported reduced HRQOL on 3 of the 5 scales assessing obesity-specific HRQOL and also the physical aspects of general HRQOL. Women also had double the rate of depression (48.5% versus 22.5%), and men had double the rate of sleep apnea (80.3% versus 40.2%). Women were younger, less obese, and were less likely to be married. No gender differences were found in the association between HRQOL and co-morbidities. However, an increasing number of co-morbidities was associated with decreasing physical and mental HRQOL. Additionally, depression was associated with decreased mental HRQOL, and coronary heart disease was associated with decreased physical HRQOL.
Women's reduced HRQOL, particularly in self-esteem, sexual life, and physical functioning, and their greater rates of depression, might play a role in their decision to seek bariatric surgery. Although we could not determine causality, this study is a first step toward understanding why women seek surgery 5 times more often than men.
本研究的目的是在美国一家减肥手术诊所中,研究减肥手术候选者在健康相关生活质量(HRQOL)、健康状况、社会人口统计学变量以及这些变量之间的相互作用方面的性别差异。女性寻求减肥手术的频率是男性的5倍。关于HRQOL性别差异的研究有限,结果也相互矛盾。
共有794名手术候选者(平均年龄42.2岁;体重指数46.9kg/m²;84.8%为女性)完成了一项与体重相关的(《体重对生活质量的影响-简化问卷》)和一项通用的(《医学结果研究简明健康调查问卷-36项》)HRQOL测量。通过问卷调查和临床访谈对健康状况进行评估。
与男性相比,女性在评估肥胖特异性HRQOL的5个量表中的3个以及一般HRQOL的身体方面报告了较低的HRQOL。女性的抑郁症发病率也高出一倍(48.5%对22.5%),而男性的睡眠呼吸暂停发病率高出一倍(80.3%对40.2%)。女性更年轻,肥胖程度更低,结婚的可能性也更小。在HRQOL与合并症之间的关联中未发现性别差异。然而,合并症数量的增加与身体和心理HRQOL的下降相关。此外,抑郁症与心理HRQOL下降相关,冠心病与身体HRQOL下降相关。
女性HRQOL降低,尤其是在自尊、性生活和身体功能方面,以及她们较高的抑郁症发病率,可能在她们决定寻求减肥手术中起作用。尽管我们无法确定因果关系,但这项研究是朝着理解为什么女性寻求手术的频率比男性高5倍迈出的第一步。