Murphy Dominic, Hotopf Matthew, Wessely Simon
King's Centre for Military Health Research, King's College London SE5 9RJ.
BMJ. 2008 Jun 30;337(7660):a220. doi: 10.1136/bmj.a220.
To assess the relation between self reported number of vaccinations received and health, and between numbers of vaccinations recorded from individuals' medical records and health.
First phase of a cohort study.
UK armed forces personnel.
4882 randomly selected military personnel deployed to Iraq since 2003 and a subset of 378 whose vaccination records were accessed.
Psychological distress, fatigue, symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder, health perception, and multiple physical symptoms.
Personnel who reported receiving two or more vaccinations on a single day were more likely to report symptoms of fatigue (adjusted risk ratio 1.17, 95% confidence interval 1.05 to 1.30), show caseness according to the general health questionnaire (1.31, 1.13 to 1.53), and have multiple physical symptoms (1.32, 1.08 to 1.60). These associations were no longer significant when number of vaccinations recorded in individuals' medical records was used as the independent variable.
Multiple vaccinations given to personnel in the UK armed forces in preparation for deployment to Iraq are not associated with adverse health consequences when vaccinations are recorded objectively from medical records. Adverse health consequences associated with self reported multiple vaccinations could be explained by recall bias.
评估自我报告的接种疫苗数量与健康之间的关系,以及从个人病历记录的接种疫苗数量与健康之间的关系。
队列研究的第一阶段。
英国武装部队人员。
自2003年以来随机挑选的4882名部署到伊拉克的军事人员,以及可获取其接种记录的378名人员的子集。
心理困扰、疲劳、创伤后应激障碍症状、健康认知和多种身体症状。
报告在同一天接种两种或更多疫苗的人员更有可能报告疲劳症状(调整风险比1.17,95%置信区间1.05至1.30),根据一般健康问卷显示为病例(1.31,1.13至1.53),并且有多种身体症状(1.32,1.08至1.60)。当将个人病历中记录的接种疫苗数量用作自变量时,这些关联不再显著。
当根据病历客观记录接种情况时,英国武装部队人员为准备部署到伊拉克而进行的多次接种与不良健康后果无关。自我报告的多次接种与不良健康后果之间的关联可能可以用回忆偏倚来解释。