Yusof Anne, Engelhardt Anette, Karlsson Asa, Bylund Lina, Vidh Pamela, Mills Karen, Wootton Mandy, Walsh Timothy R
AB Biodisk, Solna, Sweden.
J Clin Microbiol. 2008 Sep;46(9):3042-7. doi: 10.1128/JCM.00265-08. Epub 2008 Jul 2.
Glycopeptide-intermediate Staphylococcus aureus (GISA) and, in particular, heterogeneous GISA (hGISA) are difficult to detect by standard MIC methods, and thus, an accurate detection method for clinical practice and surveillances is needed. Two prototype Etest strips designed for hGISA/GISA resistance detection (GRD) were evaluated using a worldwide collection of hGISA/GISA strains covering the five major clonal lineages. A total of 150 strains comprising 15 GISA and 60 hGISA strains (defined by population analysis profiles-area under the curve [PAP-AUC]), 70 glycopeptide-susceptible S. aureus (GSSA) strains, and 5 S. aureus ATCC reference strains were tested. For standardized Etest vancomycin (VA) MIC testing, the modified Etest macromethod with VA and teicoplanin (TP) strips tested with a heavier inoculum using brain heart infusion agar (BHI) and two glycopeptide screening agar plates (6 microg/ml VA/BHI and 5 microg/ml Mueller-Hinton agar [MHA]) were tested in parallel with the two new Etest GRD strips: a VA 32 (0.5-microg/ml)-TP 32 (0.5-microg/ml) double-sided gradient (E-VA/TP) with one prototype overlaid with a nutrient (E-VA/TP+S) to enhance the growth of hGISA. The Etest GRD strips were tested with a standard 0.5-McFarland standard inoculum using MHA and MHA plus 5% blood (MHB) and were read at 18 to 24 and 48 h. The interpretive MIC cutoffs used for the new Etest GRD strips at 24 and 48 h were as follows: for GISA, TP or VA, >or=8, and a standard VA MIC of >or=6; for hGISA, TP or VA, >or=8, and a standard VA MIC of <or=4. The results on MHB at 48 h showed that E-VA/TP+S had high specificity (94%) and sensitivity (95%) in comparison to PAP-AUC and was able to detect all GISA (n = 15) and 98% of hGISA (n = 60) strains. In contrast, the glycopeptide screening plates performed poorly for hGISA. The new Etest GRD strip (E-VA/TP+S), utilizing standard media and inocula, is a simple and acceptable tool for detection of hGISA/GISA for clinical and epidemiologic purposes.
糖肽类中介金黄色葡萄球菌(GISA),尤其是异质性GISA(hGISA),难以通过标准的最低抑菌浓度(MIC)方法检测,因此,临床实践和监测需要一种准确的检测方法。使用涵盖五个主要克隆谱系的全球hGISA/GISA菌株集合,对设计用于hGISA/GISA耐药性检测(GRD)的两种原型Etest试纸条进行了评估。共测试了150株菌株,包括15株GISA和60株hGISA菌株(通过群体分析谱-曲线下面积[PAP-AUC]定义)、70株糖肽类敏感金黄色葡萄球菌(GSSA)菌株和5株金黄色葡萄球菌ATCC参考菌株。对于标准化的Etest万古霉素(VA)MIC检测,使用脑心浸液琼脂(BHI)和两种糖肽类筛选琼脂平板(6μg/ml VA/BHI和5μg/ml穆勒-欣顿琼脂[MHA]),用较重的接种物对带有VA和替考拉宁(TP)试纸条的改良Etest宏观方法进行测试,并与两种新的Etest GRD试纸条平行测试:一种VA 32(0.5μg/ml)-TP 32(0.5μg/ml)双面梯度(E-VA/TP),其中一种原型覆盖有营养物质(E-VA/TP+S)以促进hGISA的生长。使用MHA和加5%血液的MHA(MHB),用标准的0.5麦氏标准接种物对Etest GRD试纸条进行测试,并在18至24小时和48小时读取结果。新的Etest GRD试纸条在24小时和48小时的解释性MIC临界值如下:对于GISA,TP或VA,≥8,标准VA MIC≥6;对于hGISA,TP或VA,≥8,标准VA MIC≤4。48小时时在MHB上的结果表明,与PAP-AUC相比,E-VA/TP+S具有高特异性(94%)和敏感性(95%),并且能够检测所有GISA(n = 15)和98%的hGISA(n = 60)菌株。相比之下,糖肽类筛选平板对hGISA的检测效果不佳。新的Etest GRD试纸条(E-VA/TP+S),利用标准培养基和接种物,是用于临床和流行病学目的检测hGISA/GISA的一种简单且可接受的工具。