Christiansen Blaine A, Bayly Philip V, Silva Matthew J
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, and Department of Biomedical Engineering, Washington University in St. Louis, Campus Box 8233, St. Louis, MO 63110, USA.
J Biomech Eng. 2008 Aug;130(4):044502. doi: 10.1115/1.2917435.
Vibrational loading can stimulate the formation of new trabecular bone or maintain bone mass. Studies investigating vibrational loading have often used whole-body vibration (WBV) as their loading method. However, WBV has limitations in small animal studies because transmissibility of vibration is dependent on posture. In this study, we propose constrained tibial vibration (CTV) as an experimental method for vibrational loading of mice under controlled conditions. In CTV, the lower leg of an anesthetized mouse is subjected to vertical vibrational loading while supporting a mass. The setup approximates a one degree-of-freedom vibrational system. Accelerometers were used to measure transmissibility of vibration through the lower leg in CTV at frequencies from 20 Hz to 150 Hz. First, the frequency response of transmissibility was quantified in vivo, and dissections were performed to remove one component of the mouse leg (the knee joint, foot, or soft tissue) to investigate the contribution of each component to the frequency response of the intact leg. Next, a finite element (FE) model of a mouse tibia-fibula was used to estimate the deformation of the bone during CTV. Finally, strain gages were used to determine the dependence of bone strain on loading frequency. The in vivo mouse leg in the CTV system had a resonant frequency of 60 Hz for +/-0.5 G vibration (1.0 G peak to peak). Removing the foot caused the natural frequency of the system to shift from 60 Hz to 70 Hz, removing the soft tissue caused no change in natural frequency, and removing the knee changed the natural frequency from 60 Hz to 90 Hz. By using the FE model, maximum tensile and compressive strains during CTV were estimated to be on the cranial-medial and caudolateral surfaces of the tibia, respectively, and the peak transmissibility and peak cortical strain occurred at the same frequency. Strain gage data confirmed the relationship between peak transmissibility and peak bone strain indicated by the FE model, and showed that the maximum cyclic tibial strain during CTV of the intact leg was 330+/-82microepsilon and occurred at 60-70 Hz. This study presents a comprehensive mechanical analysis of CTV, a loading method for studying vibrational loading under controlled conditions. This model will be used in future in vivo studies and will potentially become an important tool for understanding the response of bone to vibrational loading.
振动负荷可以刺激新的小梁骨形成或维持骨量。研究振动负荷的研究通常使用全身振动(WBV)作为其负荷方法。然而,WBV在小动物研究中有局限性,因为振动的传递性取决于姿势。在本研究中,我们提出约束胫骨振动(CTV)作为在可控条件下对小鼠进行振动负荷的实验方法。在CTV中,将麻醉小鼠的小腿在支撑一个重物的同时施加垂直振动负荷。该装置近似于一个单自由度振动系统。使用加速度计测量在20Hz至150Hz频率下CTV中振动通过小腿的传递性。首先,在体内对传递性的频率响应进行量化,并进行解剖以去除小鼠腿部的一个组件(膝关节、足部或软组织),以研究每个组件对完整腿部频率响应的贡献。接下来,使用小鼠胫腓骨的有限元(FE)模型来估计CTV期间骨骼的变形。最后,使用应变片来确定骨应变对负荷频率的依赖性。在CTV系统中,体内小鼠腿部对于+/-0.5G振动(峰峰值1.0G)的共振频率为60Hz。去除足部导致系统的固有频率从60Hz变为70Hz,去除软组织不会导致固有频率改变,而去除膝关节则将固有频率从60Hz变为90Hz。通过使用FE模型,估计CTV期间的最大拉伸和压缩应变分别位于胫骨的颅内侧和尾外侧表面,并且峰值传递性和峰值皮质应变出现在相同频率。应变片数据证实了FE模型所示的峰值传递性与峰值骨应变之间的关系,并表明完整腿部CTV期间的最大循环胫骨应变是330+/-82微应变,且出现在60 - 70Hz。本研究对CTV进行了全面的力学分析,CTV是一种在可控条件下研究振动负荷的负荷方法。该模型将用于未来的体内研究,并有可能成为理解骨骼对振动负荷反应的重要工具。