Corfield Lorraine, Schizas Alexis, Noorani A, Williams Andrew
Department of Colorectal Surgery, St Thomas' Hospital, London, UK.
Ann R Coll Surg Engl. 2008 Jul;90(5):377-80. doi: 10.1308/003588408X301172.
Non-attendance in the out-patient department has financial costs for the NHS and clinical implications to the non-attender and those awaiting an appointment. The aim of this audit was to quantify the percentage of non-attenders at colorectal clinics in a UK teaching hospital, assess which factors affected attendance, establish why individuals fail to attend and to implement appropriate change.
The number of 'did-not-attend' patients was recorded initially for 686 appointments. Non-attenders were contacted by post or telephone to ask why this was so. The study was then repeated following telephone reminders to 391 patients due to attend clinic. The 'did-not-attend' rates in the two limbs of the completed audit cycle were then compared.
The initial study revealed a 'did-not-attend' rate of 21%, with significantly more males than females failing to attend (males, 28.6%; females, 16.9%; P = 0.001). The 'did-not-attend' rate was not significantly affected by the day of the week, time of appointment or by the weather. There were 51.7% responses to either the postal or telephone questionnaire regarding non-attendance. Of these, 27.7% did not receive an appointment letter or received it after the appointment. Hospital administration problems were cited as accounting for 34.2% of 'did-not-attends'. In the post-intervention limb, 87 patients (22%) replied to the reminder telephone call, of whom 9 (10%) cancelled their appointment and 78 (90%) confirmed that they would attend. The 'did-not-attend' rate fell to 19.7% although this was not a significant reduction.
Telephoning patients before their appointments is labour intensive and did not significantly improve the 'did-not-attend' rate. Although hospital administration errors account for a significant number of the 'did-not-attends', patients also have a responsibility to notify the hospital if they are unable to attend.
门诊患者未就诊会给英国国家医疗服务体系(NHS)带来经济成本,对未就诊者以及等待预约的患者都有临床影响。本次审计的目的是量化英国一家教学医院结直肠诊所未就诊患者的比例,评估哪些因素影响就诊率,确定患者未就诊的原因并实施适当的改进措施。
最初记录了686个预约的“未就诊”患者数量。通过邮寄或电话联系未就诊患者,询问原因。然后,对391名应就诊的患者进行电话提醒后,重复该研究。比较完整审计周期两个阶段的“未就诊”率。
初步研究显示“未就诊”率为21%,未就诊的男性明显多于女性(男性为28.6%;女性为16.9%;P = 0.001)。“未就诊”率不受星期几、预约时间或天气的显著影响。关于未就诊情况,邮寄或电话调查问卷的回复率为51.7%。其中,27.7%未收到预约信或在预约后才收到。医院管理问题被认为占“未就诊”情况的34.2%。在干预后阶段,87名患者(22%)回复了提醒电话,其中9名(10%)取消了预约,78名(90%)确认会就诊。“未就诊”率降至19.7%,但降幅不显著。
在预约前给患者打电话工作量大,且未显著提高“未就诊”率。虽然医院管理失误占“未就诊”情况的很大比例,但患者若无法就诊也有责任通知医院。