Noeller Thomas P, Smith Michael D, Holmes Laura, Cappaert Melissa, Gross Andrew J, Cole-Kelly Kathy, Rosen Kathleen R
Department of Emergency Medicine, MetroHealth Medical Center, Cleveland, Ohio, USA.
Acad Emerg Med. 2008 Nov;15(11):1199-206. doi: 10.1111/j.1553-2712.2008.00183.x. Epub 2008 Jul 14.
The authors sought to design an integrated theme-based hybrid simulation experience to educate and evaluate emergency medicine (EM) residents, to measure the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) competencies using this simulation model, to measure the impact of the simulation experience on resident performance on written tests, and to measure resident satisfaction with this simulation experience.
A theme-based hybrid simulation model that takes advantage of multiple simulation modalities in a concentrated session was developed and executed to both educate and evaluate EM residents. Simulation days took place at an integrated simulation center and replaced one 5-hour didactic block per quarter. Modified competency checklists were used to evaluate residents based on ACGME competencies. Written tests were administered before, during, and after simulation days. Residents were given the opportunity to evaluate the simulation days using standard residency program evaluation tools.
The model was proven feasible. Core competencies were measured using the model, which was executed on four occasions in 2007. Most residents met expectations based on objective checklist criteria and subjective assessment by an observing faculty member. Data from the written tests showed no overall difference in scores measured before, during, or after the simulation days. The simulation model was rated highly useful by the residents.
With the use of a highly developed simulation center and an organized, theme-based, hybrid simulation model that takes advantage of multiple simulation modalities, the authors were able to successfully develop an educational model to both train and evaluate EM residents with a high degree of resident satisfaction.
作者试图设计一种基于主题的综合混合模拟体验,以教育和评估急诊医学(EM)住院医师,使用该模拟模型衡量研究生医学教育认证委员会(ACGME)的能力,衡量模拟体验对住院医师笔试成绩的影响,并衡量住院医师对这种模拟体验的满意度。
开发并实施了一种基于主题的混合模拟模型,该模型在一次集中课程中利用多种模拟方式来教育和评估急诊医学住院医师。模拟日在综合模拟中心进行,每季度取代一个5小时的理论教学时段。使用经过修改的能力检查表,根据ACGME的能力对住院医师进行评估。在模拟日之前、期间和之后进行笔试。住院医师有机会使用标准的住院医师培训项目评估工具对模拟日进行评估。
该模型被证明是可行的。使用该模型对核心能力进行了衡量,该模型在2007年进行了四次。根据客观检查表标准和观察教员的主观评估,大多数住院医师达到了预期。笔试数据显示,模拟日之前、期间和之后的成绩没有总体差异。住院医师对模拟模型的评价很高。
通过使用高度发达的模拟中心和有组织的、基于主题的、利用多种模拟方式的混合模拟模型,作者成功地开发了一种教育模型,既能培训又能评估急诊医学住院医师,且住院医师满意度很高。