Tang C N, Tsui K K, Yang G P C, Ha J P Y, Li M K W
Department of Surgery, Pamela Youde Nethersole Eastern Hospital, Chai Wan, Hong Kong.
Hepatogastroenterology. 2008 May-Jun;55(84):846-9.
BACKGROUND/AIMS: To evaluate the results of laparoscopic exploration of the common bile duct (LECBD) in patients with previous gastrectomy.
This study is a retrospective review of a prospectively maintained database of LECBD during the period 1994-2005. Those cases of LECBD with previous open gastrectomy were sorted out and analyzed. Indications of operation included unsuccessful endoscopic extraction due to altered anatomy and some explorations were performed together with side-to-side choledochoduodenostomy so as to eliminate biliary stasis and decrease stone recurrence. The operation steps involved open insertion of trocar and creation of pneumoperitoneum, meticulous adhesiolysis, direct choledochotomy followed by clearance of biliary stones. After confirmed ductal clearance, the common bile duct was routinely closed with t-tube diversion. The perioperative parameters of these patients were analyzed and compared to those receiving open exploration of common bile duct due to previous gastrectomy during the same study period.
Of the 184 LECBD performed between 1994 and 2005, 33 patients had previous open upper gastrointestinal operations and among them 18 LECBD were performed in post-gastrectomy patients (2 with previous classical Whipple's operation). There were 10 male and 8 female patients with mean age of 77.5 (58-97 years). Of the 14 patients undergoing preoperative endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography, there were 10 failed cannulations and 4 failed extractions. Altogether 17 choledochotomies and 1 transcystic duct exploration was performed whereas 4 patients with recurrent primary stones received additional choledochoduodenostomy. Median operating time was 120 min (60-390 min). Open conversion was required in 3 patients (16.6%) because of jammed basket, extensive adhesion and "through & through" bile duct injury respectively. Postoperative complications occurred in 4 patients (22.2%), which included 3 bile leaks and also the previously mentioned bile duct injury. The median hospital stay was 9 days (4-82 days). Upon a median follow-up of 17.5 months, there was only 1 patient found to have recurrent common bile duct stone and he was managed by laparoscopic exploration and choledochoduodenostomy. When the results were compared to those 12 open explorations because of previous open gastrectomy, longer operation time (120 vs. 75 min, p=0.004) and slightly shorter hospital stay (9 vs. 14 days, p=0.104) were noted in the LECBD group but without increased complication rate (22.2 vs. 25%, p=1).
These results suggest that LECBD is worth attempting even in patients with previous open gastrectomy.
背景/目的:评估既往接受过胃切除术的患者行腹腔镜胆总管探查术(LECBD)的结果。
本研究是对1994年至2005年期间前瞻性维护的LECBD数据库进行的回顾性分析。筛选并分析既往接受过开放性胃切除术的LECBD病例。手术指征包括因解剖结构改变导致内镜下取石失败,部分探查术与胆总管十二指肠侧侧吻合术同时进行,以消除胆汁淤积并降低结石复发率。手术步骤包括开放插入套管针并建立气腹,仔细分离粘连,直接切开胆总管,随后清除胆管结石。确认胆管结石清除后,常规用T管引流关闭胆总管。分析这些患者的围手术期参数,并与同一研究期间因既往胃切除术接受开放性胆总管探查术的患者进行比较。
在1994年至2005年期间进行的184例LECBD中,33例患者既往接受过开放性上消化道手术,其中18例LECBD在胃切除术后患者中进行(2例既往接受过经典的惠普尔手术)。患者共10例男性和8例女性,平均年龄77.5岁(58 - 97岁)。在14例行术前内镜逆行胰胆管造影的患者中,10例插管失败,4例取石失败。共进行了17次胆总管切开术和1次经胆囊管探查术,4例复发性原发性结石患者接受了额外的胆总管十二指肠吻合术。中位手术时间为120分钟(60 - 390分钟)。3例患者(16.6%)因网篮嵌顿、广泛粘连和胆管“贯通伤”分别需要中转开腹。4例患者(22.2%)发生术后并发症,包括3例胆漏以及上述胆管损伤。中位住院时间为9天(4 - 82天)。中位随访17.5个月时,仅1例患者被发现有复发性胆总管结石,通过腹腔镜探查和胆总管十二指肠吻合术进行了处理。将结果与因既往开放性胃切除术而进行的12例开放性探查术比较时,LECBD组手术时间更长(120分钟对75分钟,p = 0.004),住院时间略短(9天对14天,p = 0.104),但并发症发生率未增加(22.2%对25%,p = 1)。
这些结果表明即使是既往接受过开放性胃切除术的患者,LECBD也值得尝试。