Goverover Yael, Hillary Frank G, Chiaravalloti Nancy, Arango-Lasprilla Juan Carlos, DeLuca John
Department of Occupational Therapy, New York University, New York, NY, USA.
J Clin Exp Neuropsychol. 2009 Jul;31(5):513-22. doi: 10.1080/13803390802287042. Epub 2008 Aug 11.
The present study examined the utility of using spaced learning trials (when trials are distributed over time) versus massed learning trials (consecutive learning trials) in the acquisition of everyday functional tasks. In a within-subjects design, 20 participants with multiple sclerosis (MS) and 18 healthy controls (HC) completed two route learning tasks and two paragraph reading tasks. One task in each area was presented in the "spaced" condition, in which the task was presented to the participants three times with 5-minutes break between each trial, and the second task in each area was presented in the "massed" condition, in which the task was presented three consecutive times to the participants. The dependent variables consisted of recall and recognition of the paragraphs and routes both immediately and 30 minutes following initial learning. Results showed that for paragraph learning, the spaced condition significantly enhanced memory performance for this task relative to the massed condition. However, this effect was not demonstrated in the route learning task. Thus, the spacing effect can be beneficial to enhance recall and performance of activities of daily living for individuals with MS; however, this effect was significant for verbal tasks stimuli, but not for visual tasks stimuli. It will be important during future investigations to better characterize the factors that maximize the spacing effect.
本研究考察了在获取日常功能任务时,采用间隔学习试验(试验随时间分布)与集中学习试验(连续学习试验)的效用。在一项被试内设计中,20名多发性硬化症(MS)患者和18名健康对照者(HC)完成了两项路线学习任务和两项段落阅读任务。每个领域的一项任务以“间隔”条件呈现,即该任务向参与者呈现三次,每次试验之间间隔5分钟;每个领域的第二项任务以“集中”条件呈现,即该任务向参与者连续呈现三次。因变量包括在初次学习后立即以及30分钟后对段落和路线的回忆与识别。结果表明,对于段落学习,间隔条件相对于集中条件显著提高了该任务的记忆表现。然而,在路线学习任务中未显示出这种效果。因此,间隔效应可能有利于提高MS患者的回忆能力和日常生活活动表现;然而,这种效应在言语任务刺激中显著,但在视觉任务刺激中不显著。在未来的研究中,更好地刻画最大化间隔效应的因素将很重要。