Lande R G
Department of Psychiatry, Walter Reed Army Medical Center, Washington, DC 20307-5001.
Bull Am Acad Psychiatry Law. 1991;19(2):193-201.
This article describes the military insanity defense. The success of the litigated insanity defense is explored through the number of insanity acquittals over a 28-month period. A questionnaire distributed to all United States Army psychiatrists provided information on the number of forensic evaluations performed, the number of not criminally responsible (NCR) opinions made, and the disposition of noncontested NCR opinions. The questionnaire also tested the Army psychiatrists' knowledge about recent changes in the military insanity defense. This pilot study raises interesting questions about the military insanity defense that further research can address.
本文描述了军事精神错乱辩护。通过在28个月期间因精神错乱而宣判无罪的数量来探究诉讼中的精神错乱辩护的成功率。向所有美国陆军精神病医生发放的一份调查问卷提供了关于进行的法医评估数量、做出的无刑事责任(NCR)意见数量以及无争议的NCR意见的处理情况的信息。该调查问卷还测试了陆军精神病医生对军事精神错乱辩护近期变化的了解。这项初步研究提出了一些关于军事精神错乱辩护的有趣问题,可供进一步研究探讨。