Brooks C H, Walker L R, Szorady R
Graduate Study in Health Care Administration, Cleveland State University, OH 44115.
Med Care. 1991 Aug;29(8):755-65. doi: 10.1097/00005650-199108000-00008.
The perceived quality of a journal is often a heavily weighted factor in the appraisal of faculty performance. We developed a listing of 53 prominent journals in the field of health care administration and surveyed the chairpersons of the 52 accredited graduate programs in the United States, Canada, and Puerto Rico, asking each to rate the level of achievement of a faculty member who published in each journal. Using the chi-square goodness-of-fit method for a multinomial experiment, we were able to identify six distinct "tiers" of journals and show a relationship between the subject category of a journal and its tier ranking. The implications of the study findings for faculty members are addressed, followed by a discussion of the data limitations and suggestions for future research.
在教师绩效评估中,期刊的感知质量往往是一个权重很大的因素。我们编制了一份医疗保健管理领域53种著名期刊的清单,并对美国、加拿大和波多黎各52个经认可的研究生项目的主任进行了调查,要求他们对在每种期刊上发表论文的教师的成就水平进行评分。使用多项实验的卡方拟合优度方法,我们能够识别出六个不同的期刊“层级”,并展示期刊的主题类别与其层级排名之间的关系。本文讨论了研究结果对教师的影响,随后讨论了数据局限性以及对未来研究的建议。