Pagotto Uberto, Vanuzzo Diego, Vicennati Valentina, Pasquali Renato
UO di Endocrinologia e Centro di Ricerca Biomedica Applicata (CRBA), Dipartimento di Medicina Interna e Gastroenterologia, Policlinico S. Orsola-Malpighi, Università Alma Mater Studiorum, Bologna.
G Ital Cardiol (Rome). 2008 Apr;9(4 Suppl 1):83S-93S.
Obesity is reaching epidemic proportions worldwide and it is correlated with various comorbidities, among which the most relevant are diabetes mellitus, arterial hypertension, and cardiovascular diseases. Obesity management is a modern challenge because of the rapid evolution of unfavorable lifestyles and unfortunately there are no effective treatments applicable to the large majority of obese/overweight people. The current medical attitude is to treat the complications of obesity (e.g. dyslipidemia, hypertension, diabetes, and cardiovascular diseases). However, the potential of treating obesity is enormous, bearing in mind that a volitional weight loss of 10 kg is associated with important risk factor improvement: blood pressure -10 mmHg, total cholesterol -10%, LDL cholesterol -15%, triglycerides -30%, fasting glucose -50%, HDL cholesterol +8%. Drug treatment for obesity is an evolving branch of pharmacology, burdened by severe side effects and consequences of the early drugs, withdrawn from the market, and challenged by the lack of long-term data on the effect of medications on obesity-related morbidity and mortality, first of all cardiovascular diseases. In Europe three antiobesity drugs are currently licensed: sibutramine, orlistat, and rimonabant; important trials with clinical endpoints are ongoing for sibutramine and rimonabant. While waiting for their results, it is convenient to evaluate these drugs for their effects on body weight and cardiometabolic risk factors. Sibutramine is a centrally acting serotonin/noradrenaline reuptake inhibitor that mainly increases satiety. At the level of brown adipose tissue, sibutramine can also facilitate energy expenditure by increasing thermogenesis. The long-term studies (five) documented a mean differential weight reduction of 4.45 kg for sibutramine vs placebo. Considering the principal studies, attrition rate was 43%. This drug not only reduces body weight and waist circumference, but it decreases triglycerides and uric acid as well and it increases HDL cholesterol; in diabetics it improves glycated hemoglobin. Sibutramine has conflicting effects on blood pressure: in some studies there was a minimal decrease, in some others a modest increase. In all the studies this drug increased pulse rate. Sibutramine is not recommended in patients with uncontrolled hypertension, or in case of history of cardio- and cerebrovascular disease. Orlistat is a pancreatic lipase inhibitor that reduces fat absorption by partially blocking the hydrolysis of dietary triglycerides. A recent meta-analysis evaluated 22 studies lasting for at least 12 months, in obese patients with a mean body mass index of 36.7 kg/m2, where orlistat was associated with hypocaloric diet or behavioral interventions: the net average weight loss was 2.89 kg (confidence interval 2.27-3.51 kg). Considering the principal studies, attrition rate ranged from 33 to 57%. Orlistat significantly decreases waist circumference, blood pressure, total and LDL cholesterol, but has no effect on HDL and triglycerides. This drug significantly reduced the incidence of diabetes only in subjects with impaired glucose tolerance. The major adverse effects with orlistat are mainly gastrointestinal (fatty and oily stool, fecal urgency, oily spotting, fecal incontinence) and attenuate over time. Orlistat should be avoided in patients with chronic malabsorption and cholestasis. Rimonabant is a selective antagonist of cannabinoid type 1 receptor. This drug, by inhibiting the overactivation of the endocannabinoid system, produces anorectic stimuli at the central nervous level, but also has effects on the peripheral systems involved in metabolism control, such as liver, adipose tissue, skeletal muscles, endocrine pancreas, and gastrointestinal apparatus, influencing many processes partially unknown. An ample experimental program named RIO (Rimonabant In Obesity) involved about 6600 obese or overweight patients to identify the effects of rimonabant in weight loss and associated cardiometabolic abnormalities, over and beyond a caloric restriction of 600 kcal in the treatment and placebo arms. In the four double-blind RIO trials published (Rio-North America, RIO-Europe, RIO-Lipids, RIO-Diabetes), rimonabant 20 mg significantly (p <0.001) reduced weight by 6.3-6.9 kg in the non-diabetic groups vs placebo (-1.5-1.8 kg), whereas in the diabetic subjects enrolled in RIO-Diabetes, weight loss was 5.3 vs 1.4 kg in the placebo group. Attrition rate at 1 year ranged between 40 and 50%, similar to the studies with sibutramine or orlistat. Similarly to weight loss, also waist circumference was significantly reduced by rimonabant. As for cardiometabolic parameters, rimonabant induced a significant increase in HDL cholesterol and a significant decrease in triglycerides. Even if no significant LDL reduction was achieved, the RIO-Lipids study showed a significant decrease in small dense LDL particles, more atherogenic, in rimonabant-treated subjects. Non-diabetic treated patients improved basal insulin and indirect indexes of insulin resistance, while in the RIO-Diabetes study, the only one including diabetics, glycated hemoglobin improved by 0.7% in the active treatment arm vs placebo. The effects on HDL cholesterol and glycated hemoglobin seem in a large percentage unrelated to weight loss. These effects have been confirmed by another trial, named SERENADE, evaluating the treatment in naive diabetic patients. Rimonabant is not recommended in patients with a history of depressive disorders or suicidal ideation and with uncontrolled psychiatric illness, and is contraindicated in patients with ongoing major depression or ongoing antidepressive treatment. In conclusion, despite an enormous advancement in basic research to understand the pathogenetic mechanisms at the base of obesity, the pharmacological research did not reach the therapeutic opportunities available for other chronic conditions, like hypertension and dyslipidemia. However, the few molecules available for clinical practice (sibutramine, orlistat, rimonabant) have shown, when properly used, to contribute to reduce body weight and undoubtedly improve cardiometabolic risk factors. With this preamble, according to current guidelines and pharmacoeconomic studies, patients who might benefit from antiobesity treatment are those with a body mass index > or =30 or 27-29.9 kg/m2 with major obesity-related comorbidities such as hypertension, diabetes, dyslipidemia, obstructive sleep apnea, and metabolic syndrome.
肥胖在全球正呈流行趋势,并且与多种合并症相关,其中最主要的是糖尿病、动脉高血压和心血管疾病。由于不良生活方式的迅速演变,肥胖管理成为了一项现代挑战,不幸的是,目前尚无适用于大多数肥胖/超重人群的有效治疗方法。当前的医学治疗思路是治疗肥胖的并发症(如血脂异常、高血压、糖尿病和心血管疾病)。然而,考虑到自愿减重10 kg可使重要危险因素得到显著改善:血压降低10 mmHg、总胆固醇降低10%、低密度脂蛋白胆固醇降低15%、甘油三酯降低30%、空腹血糖降低50%、高密度脂蛋白胆固醇升高8%,治疗肥胖的潜力巨大。肥胖药物治疗是药理学中一个不断发展的分支,早期药物存在严重副作用和后果,已退出市场,且缺乏关于药物对肥胖相关发病率和死亡率(尤其是心血管疾病)影响的长期数据,这给该领域带来了挑战。目前在欧洲有三种抗肥胖药物获得许可:西布曲明、奥利司他和利莫那班;针对西布曲明和利莫那班的具有临床终点的重要试验正在进行。在等待试验结果的同时,评估这些药物对体重和心血管代谢危险因素的影响是很有必要的。西布曲明是一种中枢作用的5-羟色胺/去甲肾上腺素再摄取抑制剂,主要增加饱腹感。在棕色脂肪组织水平,西布曲明还可通过增加产热促进能量消耗。五项长期研究表明,与安慰剂相比,西布曲明平均可使体重差异减少4.45 kg。综合主要研究来看,脱落率为43%。这种药物不仅能减轻体重和减小腰围,还能降低甘油三酯和尿酸水平,并提高高密度脂蛋白胆固醇水平;对糖尿病患者而言,它能改善糖化血红蛋白水平。西布曲明对血压的影响存在争议:在一些研究中血压略有下降,而在另一些研究中则有适度升高。在所有研究中,这种药物都会使脉搏率增加。未控制的高血压患者或有心血管和脑血管疾病病史的患者不建议使用西布曲明。奥利司他是一种胰脂肪酶抑制剂,通过部分阻断膳食甘油三酯的水解来减少脂肪吸收。最近一项荟萃分析评估了22项持续至少12个月的研究,这些研究针对平均体重指数为36.7 kg/m²的肥胖患者,奥利司他与低热量饮食或行为干预相结合:净平均体重减轻2.89 kg(置信区间为2.27 - 3.51 kg)。综合主要研究来看,脱落率在33%至57%之间。奥利司他能显著减小腰围、降低血压、总胆固醇和低密度脂蛋白胆固醇,但对高密度脂蛋白和甘油三酯无影响。这种药物仅在糖耐量受损的受试者中显著降低了糖尿病的发病率。奥利司他的主要不良反应主要是胃肠道方面的(脂肪便、油性便、便急、油性斑点、大便失禁),且会随着时间减轻。慢性吸收不良和胆汁淤积患者应避免使用奥利司他。利莫那班是1型大麻素受体的选择性拮抗剂。这种药物通过抑制内源性大麻素系统的过度激活,在中枢神经系统产生食欲抑制刺激,同时也对参与代谢控制的外周系统(如肝脏、脂肪组织、骨骼肌、内分泌胰腺和胃肠道)产生影响,影响许多尚不完全清楚的过程。一项名为RIO(利莫那班治疗肥胖)的大型实验项目纳入了约6600名肥胖或超重患者,以确定利莫那班在减重及相关心血管代谢异常方面的作用。在治疗组和安慰剂组中,除了600 kcal的热量限制外,RIO研究还涉及了约6600名肥胖或超重患者。在已发表的四项双盲RIO试验(RIO - 北美、RIO - 欧洲、RIO - 血脂、RIO - 糖尿病)中,与安慰剂组相比(体重减轻1.5 - 1.8 kg),非糖尿病组中20 mg利莫那班可使体重显著(p <0.001)减轻6.3 - 6.9 kg,而在RIO - 糖尿病试验中纳入的糖尿病患者中,与安慰剂组体重减轻1.4 kg相比,利莫那班组体重减轻5.3 kg。1年时的脱落率在40%至50%之间,与西布曲明或奥利司他的研究相似。与减重情况类似,利莫那班也显著减小了腰围。至于心血管代谢参数,利莫那班可使高密度脂蛋白胆固醇显著升高,甘油三酯显著降低。即使低密度脂蛋白没有显著降低,但RIO - 血脂研究表明,利莫那班治疗的受试者中,更具致动脉粥样硬化性的小而密低密度脂蛋白颗粒显著减少。非糖尿病治疗患者的基础胰岛素和胰岛素抵抗间接指标有所改善,而在唯一纳入糖尿病患者的RIO - 糖尿病研究中,与安慰剂组相比,活性治疗组的糖化血红蛋白改善了0.7%。对高密度脂蛋白胆固醇和糖化血红蛋白的影响在很大程度上似乎与体重减轻无关。另一项名为SERENADE的试验在初治糖尿病患者中评估了该治疗方法,证实了这些效果。有抑郁症病史或自杀意念且精神疾病未得到控制的患者不建议使用利莫那班,正在患有重度抑郁症或正在接受抗抑郁治疗的患者禁用。总之,尽管在理解肥胖发病机制的基础研究方面取得了巨大进展,但药理学研究尚未达到像高血压和血脂异常等其他慢性病那样的治疗水平。然而,临床实践中可用的少数几种药物(西布曲明、奥利司他、利莫那班)在正确使用时已显示出有助于减轻体重,并无疑能改善心血管代谢危险因素。基于此,根据当前指南和药物经济学研究,可能从抗肥胖治疗中获益的患者是那些体重指数≥30或27 - 29.9 kg/m²且伴有主要肥胖相关合并症(如高血压、糖尿病、血脂异常、阻塞性睡眠呼吸暂停和代谢综合征)的患者。