Arbaizar Beatriz, Gómez-Acebo Inés, Llorca Javier
Unit of Mental Health, Hospital de Laredo, 39770-Laredo (Cantabria), Spain.
Gen Hosp Psychiatry. 2008 Sep-Oct;30(5):471-5. doi: 10.1016/j.genhosppsych.2008.02.002. Epub 2008 Jul 23.
The objective of this review was to establish the efficacy of topiramate as treatment for eating disorders associated with obesity.
We reviewed all five published controlled clinical trials that tested the efficacy of topiramate in treating bulimia nervosa (BN) or binge-eating disorder (BED). Two trials involving 128 patients studied topiramate efficacy in BN, and three trials (528 patients) studied patients with BED. Data on the number of participants, weeks of follow-up, dropouts, binge frequency and weight were extracted.
Short-term treatment with topiramate is more effective than treatment with placebo in decreasing binge episodes per week (overall result: topiramate group: -5.0+/-0.6; placebo group: -3.3+/-1.2), binge days per week (topiramate group: -3.5+/-0.6; placebo group: -2.3+/-0.7) and corporal weight (topiramate group: -4.6+/-2.3; placebo group: -0.5+/-0.6) in both BN and BED. The high number of withdrawals and the small sample sizes in four of the five controlled clinical trials limit the generalizability of this result.
Topiramate is effective in the short-term treatment of eating disorders associated with obesity. Additional studies are needed to prove its efficacy in the long term and to determine the optimal effective dose.
本综述的目的是确定托吡酯作为治疗与肥胖相关的饮食失调症的疗效。
我们回顾了所有五项已发表的对照临床试验,这些试验测试了托吡酯治疗神经性贪食症(BN)或暴饮暴食症(BED)的疗效。两项涉及128名患者的试验研究了托吡酯对BN的疗效,三项试验(528名患者)研究了BED患者。提取了关于参与者数量、随访周数、退出者、暴饮暴食频率和体重的数据。
在BN和BED中,托吡酯短期治疗在降低每周暴饮暴食发作次数(总体结果:托吡酯组:-5.0±0.6;安慰剂组:-3.3±1.2)、每周暴饮暴食天数(托吡酯组:-3.5±0.6;安慰剂组:-2.3±0.7)和体重(托吡酯组:-4.6±2.3;安慰剂组:-0.5±0.6)方面比安慰剂治疗更有效。五项对照临床试验中有四项的退出人数较多且样本量较小,限制了该结果的普遍性。
托吡酯在短期治疗与肥胖相关的饮食失调症方面有效。需要进一步的研究来证明其长期疗效并确定最佳有效剂量。