West Emma, Cameron Peter, O'Reilly Gerard, Drummer Olaf H, Bystrzycki Adam
Department of Forensic Medicine, Monash University, The Alfred Hospital, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Emerg Med Australas. 2008 Aug;20(4):333-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1742-6723.2008.01110.x.
To determine the accuracy of current clinical diagnosis in recreational drug-related attendances to emergency by blood analysis.
A prospective convenience sample of 103 patients who attended hospital with suspected recreational drug-related presentations was collected. Doctors' clinical impression of drugs responsible for presentation was compared with a detailed forensic blood analysis for recreational drugs.
Among 103 samples, 80 (78%, 95% confidence intervals [CI] 70-86%) were found to have correct clinical suspicion of the recreational drug responsible for clinical presentation confirmed by laboratory analysis. Clinical diagnosis was most accurate for gamma-hydroxy butyrate (GHB) (sensitivity 97%, specificity 91%) and less accurate for amphetamines (sensitivity 61%, specificity 79%), alcohol (sensitivity 42%, specificity 84%) and opiates (sensitivity 46%, specificity 100%). Multiple drug ingestion was found in 70% (95% CI 61-79%) of samples. Sensitivity and specificity of clinical impression for prediction of multiple drug ingestion presence is 75% (95% CI 66-83%) and 85% (95% CI 78-92%), respectively.
Clinical diagnosis in recreational drug-related attendances to the ED was correct in most cases. Drugs, such as GHB, were the most accurately diagnosed. Inaccuracy in recognizing other drugs, like amphetamines, opiates and alcohol, occurs where a coingestant produces a more profound clinical picture. Multiple drug ingestion is a common scenario in recreational drug presentations to emergency.
通过血液分析确定当前在与娱乐性药物相关的急诊就诊中临床诊断的准确性。
收集了103例因疑似娱乐性药物相关症状就诊的患者,作为前瞻性便利样本。将医生对导致症状的药物的临床判断与针对娱乐性药物的详细法医血液分析结果进行比较。
在103份样本中,80份(78%,95%置信区间[CI]70 - 86%)经实验室分析证实对导致临床表现的娱乐性药物有正确的临床怀疑。γ-羟基丁酸(GHB)的临床诊断最为准确(敏感性97%,特异性91%),而苯丙胺(敏感性61%,特异性79%)、酒精(敏感性42%,特异性84%)和阿片类药物(敏感性46%,特异性100%)的诊断准确性较低。70%(95%CI 61 - 79%)的样本中发现有多种药物摄入情况。临床判断对多种药物摄入存在情况预测的敏感性和特异性分别为75%(95%CI 66 - 83%)和85%(95%CI 78 - 92%)。
在与娱乐性药物相关的急诊就诊中,大多数情况下临床诊断是正确的。像GHB这类药物诊断最为准确。在识别其他药物如苯丙胺、阿片类药物和酒精时出现不准确情况,是因为同时摄入的其他药物产生了更严重的临床症状。多种药物摄入在娱乐性药物所致急诊情况中很常见。