Koegl Christopher J, Farrington David P, Augimeri Leena K, Day David M
Institute of Criminology, University of Cambridge, UK.
Clin Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2008 Jul;13(3):419-34. doi: 10.1177/1359104508090606.
This study tested the effectiveness of a multifaceted, cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) program for antisocial children--the SNAP Under 12 Outreach Project (ORP)--in relation to age, sex and indices of treatment intensity. Study participants were 80 clinic-referred children (59 boys and 21 girls) aged 6-11 years assigned to one of the following groups: control (CG; n = 14) who did not receive the ORP, matched (MG; n = 50) who received the ORP, and experimental (EG; n = 16) who received an enhanced version of the ORP. Results indicated significant pre-post changes for the EG and MG for Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL)-measured delinquency and aggression, but no improvement for the CG. Positive relationships between the number of individual ORP components (e.g. number of children's CBT sessions) received and CBCL change scores were also found. Statistical associations tended to be larger for girls and older children (i.e. 10-11 years old) who may have been more cognitively advanced. Also, the number of children's CBT sessions predicted later convictions, even after controlling for prior CBCL delinquency scores. Findings from this study support the effectiveness of the ORP, but also highlight the need to take into account client characteristics when offering clinical treatment.
本研究测试了一项针对反社会儿童的多方面认知行为疗法(CBT)项目——12岁以下快速行动外展项目(ORP)——在年龄、性别和治疗强度指标方面的有效性。研究参与者为80名来自诊所转诊的6至11岁儿童(59名男孩和21名女孩),他们被分配到以下组之一:未接受ORP的对照组(CG;n = 14)、接受ORP的匹配组(MG;n = 50)和接受ORP强化版的实验组(EG;n = 16)。结果表明,对于实验组和匹配组,通过儿童行为检查表(CBCL)测量的犯罪和攻击行为在前后有显著变化,但对照组没有改善。还发现接受的ORP单个组成部分的数量(例如儿童CBT课程的数量)与CBCL变化分数之间存在正相关关系。对于可能认知能力更强的女孩和年龄较大的儿童(即10 - 11岁),统计关联往往更大。此外,即使在控制了先前的CBCL犯罪分数之后,儿童CBT课程的数量仍能预测后来的定罪情况。本研究结果支持ORP的有效性,但也强调在提供临床治疗时需要考虑客户特征。