Catmur Caroline, Gillmeister Helge, Bird Geoffrey, Liepelt Roman, Brass Marcel, Heyes Cecilia
Department of Psychology, University College London, London, UK.
Eur J Neurosci. 2008 Sep;28(6):1208-15. doi: 10.1111/j.1460-9568.2008.06419.x. Epub 2008 Sep 9.
The mirror system, comprising cortical areas that allow the actions of others to be represented in the observer's own motor system, is thought to be crucial for the development of social cognition in humans. Despite the importance of the human mirror system, little is known about its origins. We investigated the role of sensorimotor experience in the development of the mirror system. Functional magnetic resonance imaging was used to measure neural responses to observed hand and foot actions following one of two types of training. During training, participants in the Compatible (control) group made mirror responses to observed actions (hand responses were made to hand stimuli and foot responses to foot stimuli), whereas the Incompatible group made counter-mirror responses (hand to foot and foot to hand). Comparison of these groups revealed that, after training to respond in a counter-mirror fashion, the relative action observation properties of the mirror system were reversed; areas that showed greater responses to observation of hand actions in the Compatible group responded more strongly to observation of foot actions in the Incompatible group. These results suggest that, rather than being innate or the product of unimodal visual or motor experience, the mirror properties of the mirror system are acquired through sensorimotor learning.
镜像系统由一些皮质区域组成,这些区域能使他人的动作在观察者自身的运动系统中得以呈现,被认为对人类社会认知的发展至关重要。尽管人类镜像系统很重要,但其起源却鲜为人知。我们研究了感觉运动经验在镜像系统发育中的作用。采用功能磁共振成像来测量在两种训练类型之一后,对观察到的手部和足部动作的神经反应。在训练期间,相容(对照组)组的参与者对观察到的动作做出镜像反应(对手部刺激做出手部反应,对足部刺激做出足部反应),而不相容组做出反镜像反应(手对脚,脚对手)。对这些组的比较显示,在训练以反镜像方式做出反应后,镜像系统的相对动作观察特性发生了逆转;在相容组中对观察手部动作表现出更强反应的区域,在不相容组中对观察足部动作的反应更强。这些结果表明,镜像系统的镜像特性并非天生的,也不是单峰视觉或运动经验的产物,而是通过感觉运动学习获得的。