Sun Yu, Zhao Yan-bin, Zhou Fei-fei, Liu Zhong-jun
Department of Orthopaedics, Institute of Spine Surgery, Peking University Third Hospital, Beijing 100083, China.
Zhonghua Wai Ke Za Zhi. 2008 Mar 1;46(5):333-7.
To study the clinical and radiological outcome of Bryan cervical disc replacement and the degenerative status on adjacent segments.
The data of 26 cases of single level disc replacement with minimal 2 years follow-up were reviewed. CLINICAL OUTCOME was assessed with the JOA 17 score scale and Odom's score. Radiological assessment including range of motion and heterotopic ossification of operated level were recorded. Adjacent level degeneration on X-ray and MRI scan at baseline and at follow-up were compared.
(1) CLINICAL OUTCOME: the average JOA score was 16 with 84% improvement ratio at final follow-up in 18 cases of cervical myelopathy. Eight cases of radiculopathy were fully recovered. According to the Odom's criteria 15 cases had an excellent outcome, 7 good, 4 fair, and no case of poor result. (2) On X-ray: The range of motion (ROM) at operated level was 6.9 degrees (2 degrees-12 degrees) at baseline and 7.8 degrees (1 degree-14 degrees) at final follow-up. The heterotopic ossification around the prosthesis was observed in 7 cases and only 1 case lost movement. The average ROM was 5.3 degree in other 6 cases. There was no obvious change of disc height at adjacent levels. (3) On MRI: There was no deterioration of disc degeneration at adjacent levels at final follow-up according to Pfirrmann's classification. There was no further ligamentum flavum impingement into spinal canal observed at adjacent levels but the disc movement slightly increased at both upper and lower adjacent level at final follow-up.
The motion at operated level is preserved after minimal 2 years Bryan disc replacement with satisfied clinical outcome. The deterioration of disc degeneration at adjacent levels may be postponed.
研究Bryan颈椎间盘置换术的临床和影像学结果以及相邻节段的退变情况。
回顾了26例单节段椎间盘置换且随访至少2年的数据。用JOA 17分评分量表和奥多姆评分评估临床结果。记录影像学评估结果,包括手术节段的活动度和异位骨化情况。比较基线和随访时X线及MRI扫描的相邻节段退变情况。
(1)临床结果:18例脊髓型颈椎病患者末次随访时JOA平均评分为16分,改善率为84%。8例神经根型颈椎病患者完全康复。根据奥多姆标准,15例结果为优,7例为良,4例为可,无结果为差的病例。(2)X线表现:手术节段的活动度(ROM)基线时为6.9度(2度 - 12度),末次随访时为7.8度(1度 - 14度)。7例观察到假体周围异位骨化,仅1例活动受限。其他6例平均ROM为5.3度。相邻节段椎间盘高度无明显变化。(3)MRI表现:根据Pfirrmann分级,末次随访时相邻节段椎间盘退变无恶化。相邻节段未观察到黄韧带进一步向椎管内压迫,但末次随访时相邻上下节段椎间盘活动度略有增加。
Bryan椎间盘置换术后至少2年,手术节段的活动度得以保留,临床结果满意。相邻节段椎间盘退变的恶化可能会被延缓。