Pappas G, Agha A, Rafique G, Khan K S, Badruddin S H, Peermohamed H
Department of Community Health Sciences, The Aga Khan University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Rural Remote Health. 2008 Jul-Sep;8(3):820. Epub 2008 Sep 3.
Malnutrition and low levels of education continue to be major problems in many developing countries, especially for female children.
In Pakistan, a large-scale school lunch program was implemented in 29 of the poorest rural districts through a public-private partnership. The project provided freshly prepared meals in 4035 government primary girls' schools over a 2 year period. The primary strategy was empowerment of women in the community who volunteered to plan the meals, purchase the food, and cook and serve the meals. The project collected data from growth monitoring, attendance records, pre- and post-intervention community based surveys, focus group discussions, and the use of other ethnographic methods. A study on changes in the levels of malnutrition was based on an analytical sample of 203,116 girls who received at least two sets of body measurements at least 6 months apart.
Over the intervention period, wasting declined by almost half and school enrolment increased by 40%. Girls who entered the program early were found to have similar levels of malnutrition to girls who entered late, suggesting that factors external to the program were not associated with the decrease in malnutrition.
This study demonstrates the potential success and scalability of school feeding programs in Pakistan. Lessons learned include that synergies are found when working across sectors (health, education, and empowerment) and that there are challenges to intersectoral projects. Globalization may undermine this successful model as Pakistan considers expanded school feeding programs.
营养不良和低教育水平在许多发展中国家仍然是主要问题,尤其是对女童而言。
在巴基斯坦,通过公私合作在29个最贫困的农村地区实施了一项大规模学校午餐计划。该项目在两年时间里为4035所政府公立女子小学提供新鲜烹制的膳食。主要策略是让社区中自愿参与膳食计划、购买食品以及烹制和供应膳食的妇女获得权力。该项目从生长监测、出勤记录、干预前后的社区调查、焦点小组讨论以及其他民族志方法的运用中收集数据。一项关于营养不良水平变化的研究基于对203116名女童的分析样本,这些女童至少相隔6个月接受了两组身体测量。
在干预期间,消瘦率下降了近一半,入学率提高了40%。结果发现,早期进入该项目的女童与晚期进入的女童营养不良水平相似,这表明项目外部因素与营养不良的减少无关。
本研究证明了巴基斯坦学校供餐计划的潜在成功和可扩展性。吸取的经验教训包括跨部门(卫生、教育和赋权)合作时能产生协同效应,以及跨部门项目存在挑战。随着巴基斯坦考虑扩大学校供餐计划,全球化可能会破坏这一成功模式。