Duleep Harriet Orcutt, Dowhan Daniel J
Division of Economic Research, Office of Research, Evaluation, and Statistics, Office of Retirement and Disability Policy, Social Security Administration, USA.
Soc Secur Bull. 2008;68(1):31-50.
As the first in a trio of pieces devoted to incorporating immigration into policy models, this review of research on immigrant earnings trajectories brings to light several findings. Controlling for demographic and human capital characteristics, immigrants often start their U.S. lives at substantially lower earnings, but experience faster earnings growth than natives with comparable years of education and experience. The extent to which the earnings trajectories of immigrants and natives differ varies by country of origin, with the source-country's level of economic development being a key determinant of the size of the U.S.-born/ foreign-born difference. The earnings profiles of immigrants from economically developed countries such as Japan, Canada, or Western Europe resemble those of U.S. natives who are of the same age and education level. In contrast, the earnings of immigrants from developing nations tend to start well below those of U.S. natives with comparable education levels and experience, but rise more rapidly than their U.S. counterparts. Comparing the earnings profiles of immigrants of similar age, sex, and years of schooling, over time and across groups, a strong inverse relationship emerges between their initial earnings and their subsequent U.S. earnings growth. In other words, the lower (higher) the initial earnings are, the higher (lower) the earnings growth. These and other research results have important implications for the projection of immigrant earnings and emigration in microsimulation models, as discussed in the two articles following this one: (1) "Adding Immigrants to Microsimulation Models" and (2) "Incorporating Immigrant Flows into Microsimulation Models".
作为一系列将移民因素纳入政策模型的三篇文章中的第一篇,这篇对移民收入轨迹研究的综述揭示了几个研究发现。在控制了人口统计学和人力资本特征之后,移民在美国开始生活时的收入往往大幅低于本土居民,但与受教育年限和工作经验相当的本土居民相比,他们的收入增长更快。移民和本土居民收入轨迹的差异程度因原籍国而异,原籍国的经济发展水平是美国出生者与外国出生者收入差距大小的关键决定因素。来自经济发达国家(如日本、加拿大或西欧)的移民的收入情况与同龄且教育水平相同的美国本土居民相似。相比之下,来自发展中国家的移民的收入在一开始往往远低于受教育水平和工作经验相当的美国本土居民,但增长速度比美国同行更快。比较年龄、性别和受教育年限相似的移民群体在不同时间和不同群体之间的收入情况,他们的初始收入与随后在美国的收入增长之间呈现出强烈的负相关关系。换句话说,初始收入越低(越高),收入增长越高(越低)。正如本文之后的两篇文章《将移民纳入微观模拟模型》和《将移民流动纳入微观模拟模型》中所讨论的,这些研究结果以及其他研究结果对微观模拟模型中移民收入和移民情况的预测具有重要意义。