Carr Deborah, Jaffe Karen J, Friedman Michael A
Department of Sociology, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, New Jersey, USA.
Obesity (Silver Spring). 2008 Nov;16 Suppl 2(Suppl 2):S60-8. doi: 10.1038/oby.2008.453.
We examine the extent to which body weight affects three types of perceived interpersonal mistreatment, and evaluate whether these patterns vary by race, social class, and gender in a large sample of American men and women.
We use data from the first wave (1995) of the Midlife Development in the United States (N = 3,511), a survey of persons aged 25-74, to contrast underweight, normal weight, overweight, obese I, and obese II/III persons' reports of three types of perceived interpersonal mistreatment: disrespectful treatment; harassment/teasing; and being treated as if one has a character flaw. We assess whether these relationships are contingent upon one's gender, race, and occupational status. We control for possible confounding influences, including physical and mental health.
In the total sample, obese I and obese II/III persons report significantly higher levels of all three types of perceived mistreatment (compared to normal weight persons), even when demographic, socioeconomic status, and health characteristics are controlled. Among black men, however, obese II/III persons report significantly lower levels of all three types of perceived mistreatment, compared to their normal weight peers. Among both men and women, obese professional workers report significantly more perceived interpersonal mistreatment, compared to obese persons of lower socioeconomic status.
These findings reveal the ways that intersecting social identities may shape obese Americans' perceptions of stigmatizing interpersonal encounters.
我们研究体重对三种人际间感知到的虐待行为的影响程度,并评估这些模式在美国大量男性和女性样本中是否因种族、社会阶层和性别而有所不同。
我们使用来自美国中年发展研究(N = 3511)第一波(1995年)的数据,该研究是对年龄在25 - 74岁人群的一项调查,以对比体重过轻、正常体重、超重、肥胖I类和肥胖II/III类人群对三种人际间感知到的虐待行为的报告:不尊重的对待;骚扰/取笑;以及被当作有性格缺陷来对待。我们评估这些关系是否取决于一个人的性别、种族和职业地位。我们控制了可能的混杂影响因素,包括身心健康。
在总样本中,即使在控制了人口统计学、社会经济地位和健康特征之后,肥胖I类和肥胖II/III类人群报告的所有三种虐待行为的感知水平都显著高于正常体重人群。然而,在黑人男性中,与正常体重的同龄人相比,肥胖II/III类人群报告的所有三种虐待行为的感知水平显著更低。在男性和女性中,与社会经济地位较低的肥胖者相比,肥胖的专业人员报告的人际间感知到的虐待行为显著更多。
这些发现揭示了交叉社会身份可能塑造肥胖美国人对污名化人际遭遇的认知的方式。