Catenoix H, Mauguière F, Guénot M, Ryvlin P, Bissery A, Sindou M, Isnard J
Service de Neurologie Fonctionnelle et d'Epileptologie, Hôpital Neurologique Pierre Wertheimer, Hospices Civils de Lyon, Bron, France.
Neurology. 2008 Nov 18;71(21):1719-26. doi: 10.1212/01.wnl.0000335166.20451.88.
Intracranial stereotactic EEG recordings (SEEG) in presurgical epilepsy assessment are currently carried out in our department. The SEEG method generally used for exploration can also be used to perform radiofrequency thermocoagulations (RFTC) of the epileptic foci. To assess the indications of the RFTC procedure in the therapeutic arsenal of drug-resistant epilepsies, we report the results obtained in 41 patients to whom RFTC was proposed as a first therapeutic step before surgery or as a palliative treatment when surgery was not possible.
RFTC were produced by applying a 50-volt, 110 mA current, during 10-30 seconds within the epileptogenic zone, as identified by the SEEG investigation. Two to 31 RFTC (mean, 12) were performed per patient. The median follow-up was 19 months (range: 4 to 72).
Twenty patients (48.7%) experienced a seizure frequency decrease of at least 50%, which was over 80% in eight of them. One patient was seizure-free. The tolerance was excellent. A total of 67% of the 21 patients presenting a cortical development malformation benefited from RFTC (p = 0.052). In the group of noneligible patients for resective surgery (n = 13), six were responders to SEEG-guided RFTC and one of them was seizure-free.
This study suggests that stereotactic EEG-guided radiofrequency thermocoagulations can be proposed only as a palliative procedure, able to bring a substantial improvement of seizure frequency, to drug-resistant patients with epilepsy for whom conventional resection surgery is risky or contraindicated on the basis of invasive presurgical evaluation.
目前我院在术前癫痫评估中开展了颅内立体定向脑电图记录(SEEG)。通常用于探索的SEEG方法也可用于对癫痫病灶进行射频热凝术(RFTC)。为评估RFTC手术在耐药性癫痫治疗手段中的适应证,我们报告了41例患者的治疗结果,这些患者被建议将RFTC作为手术前的首个治疗步骤,或在无法进行手术时作为姑息治疗。
在SEEG检查确定的致痫区内,通过施加50伏、110毫安的电流,持续10至30秒,进行RFTC。每位患者进行2至31次RFTC(平均12次)。中位随访时间为19个月(范围:4至72个月)。
20例患者(48.7%)癫痫发作频率至少降低了50%,其中8例降低超过80%。1例患者无癫痫发作。耐受性良好。21例存在皮质发育畸形的患者中,共有67%从RFTC中获益(p = 0.052)。在不符合切除手术条件的患者组(n = 13)中,6例对SEEG引导下的RFTC有反应,其中1例无癫痫发作。
本研究表明,立体定向脑电图引导下的射频热凝术仅可作为一种姑息性手术,对于那些根据侵入性术前评估,传统切除手术存在风险或禁忌的耐药性癫痫患者,能够显著改善癫痫发作频率。