School of Nursing, University of British Columbia, T201-2211 Wesbrook Mall, Vancouver, BC, Canada V6T 2B5.
Nurse Educ Pract. 2005 Jan;5(1):30-9. doi: 10.1016/j.nepr.2004.03.003.
This paper focuses upon an exploration of undergraduate students' perceptions of clinical decision-making skills in their final year of a baccalaureate adult nursing programme. A phenomenological study was carried out, with a sample of 21 students undertaking their nursing management module. They produced a consensus concept mapping of clinical decision-making and completed self-assessment questionnaires exploring their personal confidence and understanding of clinical decision-making. Twelve students from this group also participated in a focus group interview to further explore their conceptualisation of clinical decision-making. Although the students demonstrated a complex theoretical conceptualisation of clinical decision-making, they tended to focus on the impact of clinical decision-making, and the value of concrete experience rather than the value of cognitive skills in the process and application of decision-making theory to practice. They linked their level of clinical knowledge and experience with their level of skill in clinical decision-making, rather than their cognitive ability. The students identified the patient as the focus of clinical decision-making, and reflected concerns about the personal impact of clinical decision-making on themselves, and the quality of care as the main factors influencing their decisions.
本文聚焦于探讨本科护生在学士学位成人护理项目最后一年对临床决策技能的看法。采用现象学研究方法,对 21 名正在学习护理管理模块的学生进行了研究。他们对临床决策进行了共识概念映射,并完成了自我评估问卷,以探索他们对临床决策的个人信心和理解。该组中的 12 名学生还参加了焦点小组访谈,以进一步探讨他们对临床决策的概念化。尽管学生们对临床决策表现出了复杂的理论概念化,但他们往往更关注临床决策的影响,以及具体经验的价值,而不是认知技能在决策理论应用于实践中的价值。他们将自己的临床知识和经验水平与临床决策技能水平联系起来,而不是与认知能力联系起来。学生们将患者确定为临床决策的焦点,并反映出对临床决策对自己的个人影响以及对护理质量的关注是影响他们决策的主要因素。