Harlak H, Gemalmaz A, Gurel F S, Dereboy C, Ertekin K
Adnan Menderes University, Faculty of Science and Letters, Department of Psychology, Aydin, Turkey.
Educ Health (Abingdon). 2008 Jul;21(2):62. Epub 2008 Aug 23.
This study explored and compared medical students' attitudes toward communication skills and empathic tendency before and after communication skills training.
Fifty-nine first-year students voluntarily completed a questionnaire consisting of the Communication Skills Attitudes Scale and the Empathic Tendency Scale before and after training. K-means cluster analysis and Student's t-test were used for statistical analysis.
In the pre-test, 49% of the students had positive attitudes toward communication skills learning and 59% had higher empathic tendencies. In post-test, the mean score in the positive attitude group decreased significantly, whereas there was no change in the negative attitude group. In the high empathy group, empathy scores did not change significantly after training; however, in the low empathy group, empathic tendency significantly increased.
As students' low empathic tendency level became higher and positive attitudes toward communication skills learning significantly changed in a negative direction after training, we observed that our training programme seems to have an effect that makes students similar to each other in terms of their empathic tendency and attitudes toward communication skills learning. Women had more positive attitudes toward communication skills and their empathic tendencies were higher than men's.
Our findings suggest that our curriculum is in need of further examination and modification. Future studies with larger samples are needed to investigate the effects of communication skills training on students' attitudes.
本研究探讨并比较了医学生在沟通技能培训前后对沟通技能的态度和共情倾向。
59名一年级学生在培训前后自愿完成了一份由沟通技能态度量表和共情倾向量表组成的问卷。采用K均值聚类分析和学生t检验进行统计分析。
在预测试中,49%的学生对沟通技能学习持积极态度,59%的学生有较高的共情倾向。在测试后,积极态度组的平均得分显著下降,而消极态度组没有变化。在高共情组中,培训后共情得分没有显著变化;然而,在低共情组中,共情倾向显著增加。
由于学生较低的共情倾向水平在培训后有所提高,且对沟通技能学习的积极态度显著向消极方向转变,我们观察到我们的培训计划似乎产生了一种效果,使学生在共情倾向和对沟通技能学习的态度方面彼此相似。女性对沟通技能的态度更积极,她们的共情倾向高于男性。
我们的研究结果表明,我们的课程需要进一步审查和修改。未来需要更大样本的研究来调查沟通技能培训对学生态度的影响。