Cobley Stephen P, Schorer Joerg, Baker Joseph
Leeds Metropolitan University, Carnegie Faculty of Sport & Education, Leeds, UK.
J Sports Sci. 2008 Dec;26(14):1531-8. doi: 10.1080/02640410802298250.
Relative age effects (RAEs) refer to the specific selection, participation and attainment (dis)advantages which occur as a result of physical and cognitive differences within annual age-grouped cohorts. The present study tracked the existence of RAEs in professional German soccer by examining RAEs in players, head coaches and referees who represented professional soccer clubs or officiated in the Bundesliga from 1963/64 to 2006/07. An additional objective was to consider the social-cultural mechanisms responsible for RAEs, so for a similar period, population and soccer participation information was also obtained. When players were categorised into half decade groups, chi-square analyses predominantly showed RAEs across the history of the Bundesliga, irrespective of dates used for annual age grouping in junior/youth soccer. RAEs were also apparent for head coaches but not for referees. Participation data indicated consistent and progressive growth from 1950 to 1990. RAEs influence the likelihood of attaining professional player and coaching status in German soccer. With many coaches being former players, inequalities associated with annual age-grouping appear to extend beyond a playing career. Officiating was not affected, with referees suggested to emerge from an alternative development pathway. Increased popularity of soccer may have propagated RAEs over time, through intensification of competition and selection mechanisms.
相对年龄效应(RAEs)指的是在按年龄分组的年度队列中,由于身体和认知差异而产生的特定选择、参与和成就(不利)优势。本研究通过考察1963/64至2006/07年间代表职业足球俱乐部或在德甲执法的球员、主教练和裁判的相对年龄效应,追踪德国职业足球中相对年龄效应的存在情况。另一个目标是考虑导致相对年龄效应的社会文化机制,因此在同一时期,还获取了人口和足球参与信息。当将球员按五年一组进行分类时,卡方分析主要显示在德甲历史上存在相对年龄效应,无论在青少年足球中用于年度年龄分组的日期如何。相对年龄效应在主教练中也很明显,但在裁判中则不明显。参与数据表明,从1950年到1990年参与人数持续且逐步增长。相对年龄效应影响在德国足球中获得职业球员和教练身份的可能性。由于许多教练曾是球员,与年度年龄分组相关的不平等似乎会延续到球员的职业生涯之外。裁判工作不受影响,裁判似乎是通过另一条发展途径成长起来的。随着时间的推移,足球运动受欢迎程度的提高可能通过竞争和选拔机制的强化传播了相对年龄效应。