Clarke M G, Kennedy K P, MacDonagh R P
Department of General Surgery & Urology, Taunton & Somerset Hospital, Musgrove Park, Taunton, UK.
Med Decis Making. 2009 Mar-Apr;29(2):239-46. doi: 10.1177/0272989X08327114. Epub 2008 Dec 1.
To develop a clinical prediction model enabling the calculation of an individual patient's life expectancy (LE) and survival probability based on age, sex, and comorbidity for use in the joint decision-making process regarding medical treatment.
A computer software program was developed with a team of 3 clinicians, 2 professional actuaries, and 2 professional computer programmers. This incorporated statistical spreadsheet and database access design methods. Data sources included life insurance industry actuarial rating factor tables (public and private domain), Government Actuary Department UK life tables, professional actuarial sources, and evidence-based medical literature. The main outcome measures were numerical and graphical display of comorbidity-adjusted LE; 5-, 10-, and 15-year survival probability; in addition to generic UK population LE.
Nineteen medical conditions, which impacted significantly on LE in actuarial terms and were commonly encountered in clinical practice, were incorporated in the final model. Numerical and graphical representations of statistical predictions of LE and survival probability were successfully generated for patients with either no comorbidity or a combination of the 19 medical conditions included. Validation and testing, including actuarial peer review, confirmed consistency with the data sources utilized.
The evidence-based actuarial data utilized in this computer program design represent a valuable resource for use in the clinical decision-making process, where an accurate objective assessment of patient LE can so often make the difference between patients being offered or denied medical and surgical treatment. Ongoing development to incorporate additional comorbidities and enable Web-based access will enhance its use further.
开发一种临床预测模型,能够根据年龄、性别和合并症计算个体患者的预期寿命(LE)和生存概率,以用于医疗治疗的联合决策过程。
与3名临床医生、2名专业精算师和2名专业计算机程序员组成的团队共同开发了一个计算机软件程序。该程序采用了统计电子表格和数据库访问设计方法。数据来源包括人寿保险业精算评级因素表(公共和私人领域)、英国政府精算部门生命表、专业精算来源以及循证医学文献。主要结局指标包括合并症调整后预期寿命的数值和图形显示;5年、10年和15年生存概率;以及英国普通人群的预期寿命。
最终模型纳入了19种对精算意义上的预期寿命有显著影响且在临床实践中常见的医疗状况。成功生成了无合并症或包含这19种医疗状况组合的患者预期寿命和生存概率的统计预测数值和图形表示。包括精算同行评审在内的验证和测试证实了与所使用数据源的一致性。
该计算机程序设计中使用的循证精算数据是临床决策过程中的宝贵资源,在该过程中,对患者预期寿命进行准确客观的评估往往会决定患者是否能接受医疗和手术治疗。纳入更多合并症并实现基于网络访问的持续开发将进一步提高其应用价值。