Alexandre Ana, Laranjo Marta, Young J Peter W, Oliveira Solange
Laboratório de Microbiologia do Solo, Instituto de Ciências Agrárias Mediterrânicas, Universidade de Evora, Evora, Portugal.
Int J Syst Evol Microbiol. 2008 Dec;58(Pt 12):2839-49. doi: 10.1099/ijs.0.2008/001636-0.
In the past, bacterial phylogeny relied almost exclusively on 16S rRNA gene sequence analysis. More recently, multilocus sequence analysis has been used to infer organismal phylogenies. In this study, the dnaJ chaperone gene was investigated as a marker for phylogeny studies in alphaproteobacteria. Preliminary analysis of G+C contents and G+C3s contents (the G+C content of the synonymous third codon position) showed no clear evidence of horizontal transfer of this gene in proteobacteria. dnaJ-based phylogenies were then analysed at three taxonomic levels: the Proteobacteria, the Alphaproteobacteria and the genus Mesorhizobium. Dendrograms based on DnaJ and 16S rRNA gene sequences revealed the same topology described previously for the Proteobacteria. These results indicate that the DnaJ phylogenetic signal is able to reproduce the accepted relationships among the five classes of the Proteobacteria. At a lower taxonomic level, using 20 alphaproteobacteria, the 16S rRNA gene-based phylogeny is distinct from the one based on DnaJ sequence analysis. Although the same clusters are generated, only the topology of the DnaJ tree is consistent with broader phylogenies from recent studies based on concatenated alignments of multiple core genes. For example, the DnaJ tree shows the two clusters within the Rhizobiales as closely related, as expected, while the 16S rRNA gene-based phylogeny shows them as distantly related. In order to evaluate the phylogenetic performance of dnaJ at the genus level, a multilocus analysis based on five housekeeping genes (atpD, gapA, gyrB, recA and rplB) was performed for ten Mesorhizobium species. In contrast to the 16S rRNA gene, the DnaJ sequence analysis generated a tree similar to the multilocus dendrogram. For identification of chickpea mesorhizobium isolates, a dnaJ nucleotide sequence-based tree was used. Despite different topologies, 16S rRNA gene- and dnaJ-based trees led to the same species identification. This study suggests that the dnaJ gene is a good phylogenetic marker, particularly for the class Alphaproteobacteria, since its phylogeny is consistent with phylogenies based on multilocus approaches.
过去,细菌系统发育几乎完全依赖于16S rRNA基因序列分析。最近,多位点序列分析已被用于推断生物系统发育。在本研究中,对dnaJ伴侣基因作为α-变形菌纲系统发育研究的标记进行了调查。对G+C含量和G+C3s含量(同义密码子第三位的G+C含量)的初步分析表明,该基因在变形菌纲中没有明显的水平转移证据。然后在三个分类水平上分析基于dnaJ的系统发育:变形菌纲、α-变形菌纲和中生根瘤菌属。基于DnaJ和16S rRNA基因序列的系统发育树揭示了先前描述的变形菌纲相同的拓扑结构。这些结果表明,DnaJ系统发育信号能够重现变形菌纲五个类群之间公认的关系。在较低的分类水平上,使用20种α-变形菌,基于16S rRNA基因的系统发育与基于DnaJ序列分析的系统发育不同。虽然生成了相同的聚类,但只有DnaJ树的拓扑结构与最近基于多个核心基因串联比对的研究中更广泛的系统发育一致。例如,正如预期的那样,DnaJ树显示根瘤菌目中的两个聚类密切相关,而基于16S rRNA基因的系统发育显示它们关系较远。为了评估dnaJ在属水平上的系统发育性能,对10种中生根瘤菌进行了基于五个管家基因(atpD、gapA、gyrB、recA和rplB)的多位点分析。与16S rRNA基因不同,DnaJ序列分析生成的树与多位点系统发育树相似。为了鉴定鹰嘴豆中生根瘤菌分离株,使用了基于dnaJ核苷酸序列的树。尽管拓扑结构不同,但基于16S rRNA基因和dnaJ的树导致了相同的物种鉴定。本研究表明,dnaJ基因是一个很好的系统发育标记,特别是对于α-变形菌纲,因为它的系统发育与基于多位点方法的系统发育一致。