Martino Rosemary, Silver Frank, Teasell Robert, Bayley Mark, Nicholson Gordon, Streiner David L, Diamant Nicholas E
Department of Speech-Language Pathology, University of Toronto, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Stroke. 2009 Feb;40(2):555-61. doi: 10.1161/STROKEAHA.107.510370. Epub 2008 Dec 12.
Dysphagia occurs in 55% of all acute stroke patients. Early identification of dysphagia from screening can lead to earlier treatments and thereby reduce complications. We designed and validated a new bedside dysphagia screening tool-the Toronto Bedside Swallowing Screening Test (TOR-BSST) for stroke survivors in acute and rehabilitative settings.
The TOR-BSST initially contained 5 items with proven high predictive ability for dysphagia. Trained screeners administer and score the TOR-BSST in less than 10 minutes. Trained nurses from 2 acute and 2 rehabilitation facilities administered the TOR-BSST to consecutively admitted stroke inpatients. A positive screen identified patients at risk for dysphagia. Blinded repeat screenings were conducted within 24 hours. Test-retest reliability was established with the first 50 administrations at an ICC=0.92 (CI, 0.85 to 0.96). Items were eliminated if they contributed <or=5% to the total score and were judged clinically impractical. 20% of all enrolled patients were randomly allocated to gold standard videofluoroscopic assessment of swallowing and findings rated independently by 4 blinded experts. Adequate validity was set at sensitivity >or=90% and negative predictive value >or=90%.
311 stroke inpatients were enrolled; 103 acute and 208 rehabilitation. Screening was positive in 59.2% acute and 38.5% rehabilitation patients. The pharyngeal sensation item did not meet inclusion criteria and was eliminated. The TOR-BSST demonstrated excellent validity with sensitivity at 91.3% (CI, 71.9 to 98.7), and negative predictive values at 93.3% in acute and 89.5% in rehabilitation settings.
The TOR-BSST is a simple accurate tool to identify stroke patients with dysphagia regardless of severity and setting.
55%的急性脑卒中患者会出现吞咽困难。通过筛查早期识别吞咽困难可实现更早治疗,从而减少并发症。我们设计并验证了一种新的床边吞咽困难筛查工具——多伦多床边吞咽筛查测试(TOR - BSST),用于急性和康复期的脑卒中幸存者。
TOR - BSST最初包含5个项目,已证实对吞咽困难具有较高预测能力。经过培训的筛查人员在不到10分钟的时间内进行TOR - BSST的管理和评分。来自2家急症医院和2家康复机构的经过培训的护士对连续收治的脑卒中住院患者进行TOR - BSST测试。阳性筛查可识别有吞咽困难风险的患者。在24小时内进行盲法重复筛查。在前50次测试中建立了重测信度,组内相关系数(ICC)=0.92(95%置信区间,0.85至0.96)。如果项目对总分的贡献≤5%且被判定临床不可行,则将其剔除。所有入组患者的20%被随机分配至吞咽的金标准视频透视评估组,由4名盲法专家独立评定结果。设定足够的效度为敏感度≥90%且阴性预测值≥90%。
共纳入311例脑卒中住院患者,其中103例为急症患者,208例为康复期患者。急症患者中筛查阳性率为59.2%,康复期患者中为38.5%。咽部感觉项目未达到纳入标准,被剔除。TOR - BSST显示出极佳的效度,急症患者中的敏感度为91.3%(95%置信区间,71.9至98.7),阴性预测值在急症患者中为93.3%,在康复期患者中为89.5%。
TOR - BSST是一种简单准确的工具,可用于识别有吞咽困难的脑卒中患者,无论其严重程度及所处阶段如何。