Berninger Virginia W, Nielsen Kathleen H, Abbott Robert D, Wijsman Ellen, Raskind Wendy
Educational Psychology, University of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195-3600, USA.
J Sch Psychol. 2008 Apr;46(2):151-72. doi: 10.1016/j.jsp.2007.02.007. Epub 2007 Apr 2.
Gender differences in mean level of reading and writing skills were examined in 122 children (80 boys and 42 girls) and 200 adults (115 fathers and 85 mothers) who showed behavioral markers of dyslexia in a family genetics study. Gender differences were found in writing and replicated prior results for typically developing children: Boys and men were more impaired in handwriting and composing than were girls and women, but men, who were more impaired in those writing skills, were also more impaired in spelling than women. Men were more impaired than women in accuracy and rate of reading passages orally, but boys were not more impaired than girls on any of the reading measures. Males were consistently more impaired than females in orthographic skills, which may be the source of gender differences in writing, but not motor skills. Population-based studies that report gender differences in reading in children with dyslexia may be confounding reading and writing disorders--the latter being the true source of gender differences in both children and adults with dyslexia.
在一项家庭遗传学研究中,对122名儿童(80名男孩和42名女孩)和200名成年人(115名父亲和85名母亲)进行了读写技能平均水平的性别差异研究,这些人都表现出诵读困难的行为特征。研究发现了写作方面的性别差异,并重复了先前针对正常发育儿童的研究结果:男孩和男性在书写和作文方面比女孩和女性受损更严重,但在这些写作技能方面受损更严重的男性,在拼写方面也比女性受损更严重。男性在口头阅读段落的准确性和速度方面比女性受损更严重,但在任何阅读测试中男孩并不比女孩受损更严重。在正字法技能方面,男性始终比女性受损更严重,这可能是写作中性别差异的根源,但在运动技能方面并非如此。基于人群的研究报告了诵读困难儿童在阅读方面的性别差异,这可能混淆了阅读和写作障碍——后者才是诵读困难儿童和成人中性别差异的真正根源。