Bianchin A, Pellizzato N, Martano L, Castioni C A
Anesthesia and Intensive Care Unit, Azienda ULSS 8, Hospital of Montebelluna, Treviso, Italy.
Minerva Anestesiol. 2009 Jun;75(6):357-62. Epub 2008 Dec 17.
The aim of this study was to investigate the use of therapeutic hypothermia (TH) in Italian Intensive Care Units (ICUs).
After being contacted by phone, a structured questionnaire to evaluate the use of TH was sent to all Italian ICUs. The questionnaire was aimed at determining the extent of TH use (indications, methods employed, target temperature, side effects) as well as the reasons why some ICUs did not make use of TH for the treatment of cardiac arrest patients.
Out of the 448 ICUs contacted, 90% (n=404) returned the questionnaire completely filled in. Sixty-six responders (16%) made use of TH for post-resuscitation care, and 4% used TH for other clinical scenarios (10 ICUs for traumatic brain injury; 5 ICUs for other reasons). More than half used TH not only for cardiac arrest subsequent to ventricular fibrillation (VF), but also for non-VF cardiac arrest with the duration of TH treatment being within the time suggested by advanced cardiac life support guidelines. On the other hand, 80% of questionnaire responders did not use TH, mainly because they felt they did not have enough data/experience (45%), or simply because they had never thought about it (18%).
Despite authoritative data supporting its effectiveness and safety, use of TH as part of the therapy in a post-resuscitation period in Italian ICUs remains low. The reasons for not using it are not completely justified and suggest that an educational program is advisable in order to boost the utilization of TH in Italy.
本研究旨在调查治疗性低温(TH)在意大利重症监护病房(ICU)中的使用情况。
通过电话联系后,向所有意大利ICU发送了一份评估TH使用情况的结构化问卷。该问卷旨在确定TH的使用程度(适应症、采用的方法、目标温度、副作用)以及一些ICU未使用TH治疗心脏骤停患者的原因。
在联系的448家ICU中,90%(n = 404)完全填写并返回了问卷。66名受访者(16%)在复苏后护理中使用了TH,4%在其他临床场景中使用了TH(10家ICU用于创伤性脑损伤;5家ICU用于其他原因)。超过一半的受访者不仅在心室颤动(VF)后心脏骤停时使用TH,而且在非VF心脏骤停时也使用TH,TH治疗持续时间在高级心脏生命支持指南建议的时间范围内。另一方面,80%的问卷受访者未使用TH,主要是因为他们觉得没有足够的数据/经验(45%),或者仅仅是因为他们从未考虑过(18%)。
尽管有权威数据支持其有效性和安全性,但在意大利ICU中,TH作为复苏后治疗的一部分的使用率仍然很低。不使用TH的原因并不完全合理,这表明为了提高TH在意大利的利用率,开展一项教育计划是可取的。