Rhodes Tim
Centre for Research on Drugs and Health Behaviour, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, University of London, UK.
Int J Drug Policy. 2009 May;20(3):193-201. doi: 10.1016/j.drugpo.2008.10.003. Epub 2009 Jan 14.
A 'risk environment' framework promotes an understanding of harm, and harm reduction, as a matter of 'contingent causation'. Harm is contingent upon social context, comprising interactions between individuals and environments. There is a momentum of interest in understanding how the relations between individuals and environments impact on the production and reduction of drug harms, and this is reflected by broader debates in the social epidemiology, political economy, and sociology of health. This essay maps some of these developments, and a number of challenges. These include: social epidemiological approaches seeking to capture the socially constructed and dynamic nature of individual-environment interactions; political-economic approaches giving sufficient attention to how risk is situated differentially in local contexts, and to the role of agency and experience; understanding how public health as well as harm reduction discourses act as sites of 'governmentality' in risk subjectivity; and focusing on the logics of everyday habits and practices as a means to understanding how structural risk environments are incorporated into experience. Overall, the challenge is to generate empirical and theoretical work which encompasses both 'determined' and 'productive' relations of risk across social structures and everyday practices. A risk environment approach brings together multiple resources and methods in social science, and helps frame a 'social science for harm reduction'.
“风险环境”框架促进了对伤害以及减少伤害的理解,将其视为一种“偶然因果关系”。伤害取决于社会背景,包括个人与环境之间的相互作用。人们对理解个人与环境之间的关系如何影响药物伤害的产生和减少有着浓厚的兴趣,这在社会流行病学、健康政治经济学和健康社会学的更广泛辩论中得到了体现。本文梳理了其中的一些发展情况以及若干挑战。这些挑战包括:社会流行病学方法试图捕捉个人与环境相互作用的社会建构性和动态本质;政治经济学方法充分关注风险在当地背景下的不同定位方式,以及能动性和经验的作用;理解公共卫生以及减少伤害话语如何在风险主体性中充当“治理”场所;关注日常习惯和实践的逻辑,以此作为理解结构性风险环境如何融入经验的一种手段。总体而言,挑战在于开展涵盖社会结构和日常实践中风险的“决定性”和“生产性”关系的实证和理论研究。风险环境方法整合了社会科学中的多种资源和方法,并有助于构建一门“减少伤害的社会科学”。