Schafer Robin J, Lacadie Cheryl, Vohr Betty, Kesler Shelli R, Katz Karol H, Schneider Karen C, Pugh Kenneth R, Makuch Robert W, Reiss Allan L, Constable R Todd, Ment Laura R
Department of Diagnostic Imaging, Magnetic Resonance Research Center, Yale University School of Medicine, PO Box 208043, New Haven, CT 06520, USA.
Brain. 2009 Mar;132(Pt 3):661-70. doi: 10.1093/brain/awn353. Epub 2009 Jan 21.
Recent data suggest recovery of language systems but persistent structural abnormalities in the prematurely born. We tested the hypothesis that subjects who were born prematurely develop alternative networks for processing language. Subjects who were born prematurely (n = 22; 600-1250 g birth weight), without neonatal brain injury on neonatal cranial ultrasound, and 26 term control subjects were examined with a functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) semantic association task, the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III) and the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF). In-magnet task accuracy and response times were calculated, and fMRI data were evaluated for the effect of group on blood oxygen level dependent (BOLD) activation, the correlation between task accuracy and activation and the functional connectivity between regions activating to task. Although there were differences in verbal IQ and CELF scores between the preterm (PT) and term control groups, there were no significant differences for either accuracy or response time for the in-magnet task. Both groups activated classic semantic processing areas including the left superior and middle temporal gyri and inferior frontal gyrus, and there was no significant difference in activation patterns between groups. Clear differences between the groups were observed in the correlation between task accuracy and activation to task at P < 0.01, corrected for multiple comparisons. Left inferior frontal gyrus correlated with accuracy only for term controls and left sensory motor areas correlated with accuracy only for PT subjects. Left middle temporal gyri correlated with task accuracy for both groups. Connectivity analyses at P < 0.001 revealed the importance of a circuit between left middle temporal gyri and inferior frontal gyrus for both groups. In addition, the PT subjects evidenced greater connectivity between traditional language areas and sensory motor areas but significantly fewer correlated areas within the frontal lobes when compared to term controls. We conclude that at 12 years of age, children born prematurely and children born at term had no difference in performance on a simple lexical semantic processing task and activated similar areas. Connectivity analyses, however, suggested that PT subjects rely upon different neural pathways for lexical semantic processing when compared to term controls. Plasticity in network connections may provide the substrate for improving language skills in the prematurely born.
近期数据表明,早产者语言系统可恢复,但存在持续性结构异常。我们检验了以下假设:早产个体可形成处理语言的替代网络。对早产(出生体重600 - 1250克,n = 22)且新生儿头颅超声检查无新生儿脑损伤的个体,以及26名足月对照个体进行了功能性磁共振成像(fMRI)语义关联任务、韦氏儿童智力量表第三版(WISC - III)和语言基本能力临床评估(CELF)检查。计算了磁体任务的准确性和反应时间,并评估了fMRI数据中组对血氧水平依赖(BOLD)激活的影响、任务准确性与激活之间的相关性以及激活区域之间的功能连接性。尽管早产(PT)组和足月对照组在言语智商和CELF分数上存在差异,但磁体任务的准确性或反应时间均无显著差异。两组均激活了经典语义处理区域,包括左侧颞上回、颞中回和额下回,且两组激活模式无显著差异。在经多重比较校正后,P < 0.01时观察到两组在任务准确性与任务激活之间的相关性存在明显差异。仅足月对照组的左侧额下回与准确性相关,仅PT组的左侧感觉运动区与准确性相关。两组的左侧颞中回均与任务准确性相关。P < 0.001时的连接性分析表明,左侧颞中回与额下回之间的回路对两组均很重要。此外,与足月对照组相比,PT组个体在传统语言区域与感觉运动区域之间表现出更强的连接性,但额叶内的相关区域明显更少。我们得出结论,12岁时,早产儿童和足月出生儿童在简单词汇语义处理任务上的表现无差异,且激活的区域相似。然而,连接性分析表明,与足月对照组相比,PT组个体在词汇语义处理上依赖不同的神经通路。网络连接的可塑性可能为改善早产者的语言技能提供基础。