Gibbs Iris C, Patil Chirag, Gerszten Peter C, Adler John R, Burton Steven A
Department of Radiation Oncology, Stanford University Medical Center, Stanford, California 94305-5847, USA.
Neurosurgery. 2009 Feb;64(2 Suppl):A67-72. doi: 10.1227/01.NEU.0000341628.98141.B6.
Spinal cord injury is arguably the most feared complication in radiotherapy and has historically limited the aggressiveness of spinal tumor treatment. We report a case series of 6 patients treated with radiosurgery who developed delayed myelopathy.
Between 1996 and 2005, 1075 patients with benign or malignant spinal tumors were treated by CyberKnife (Accuray, Inc., Sunnyvale, CA) robotic radiosurgery at Stanford University Medical Center and the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center. Patients were followed prospectively with clinical and radiographic assessments at 1- to 6-month intervals. A retrospective review identified patients who developed delayed radiation-induced myelopathy. Six patients (5 women, 1 man) with a mean age of 48 years (range, 25-61 years) developed delayed myelopathy at a mean of 6.3 months (range, 2-9 months) after spinal radiosurgery. Three tumors were metastatic; 3 were benign. The metastases were in the upper to midthoracic spine, whereas the benign tumors were partially in the cervical region. Three cases involved previous radiation therapy.
Dose volume histograms were generated for target and critical structures. Clinical and dosimetric factors were analyzed for factors predictive of spinal cord injury. Specific dosimetric factors contributing to this complication could not be identified, but one-half of the patients with myelopathy received spinal cord biological equivalent doses exceeding 8 Gy.
Delayed myelopathy after radiosurgery is uncommon with the dose schedules used in this case series. Radiation injury to the spinal cord occurred over a spectrum of dose parameters that prevented identification of specific dosimetric factors contributing to this complication. Primarily, biological equivalent dose estimates were not usable for defining spinal cord tolerance to hypofractionated dose schedules. We recommend limiting the volume of spinal cord treated above an 8-Gy equivalent dose, because half of the complications occurred beyond this level.
脊髓损伤可谓是放射治疗中最令人担忧的并发症,并且在历史上一直限制着脊柱肿瘤治疗的积极性。我们报告一组接受放射外科治疗后发生迟发性脊髓病的6例患者。
1996年至2005年间,斯坦福大学医学中心和匹兹堡大学医学中心使用射波刀(Accuray公司,加利福尼亚州桑尼维尔)机器人放射外科对1075例良性或恶性脊柱肿瘤患者进行了治疗。对患者进行前瞻性随访,每隔1至6个月进行临床和影像学评估。通过回顾性研究确定发生迟发性放射性脊髓病的患者。6例患者(5名女性,1名男性),平均年龄48岁(范围25 - 61岁),在脊柱放射外科治疗后平均6.3个月(范围2 - 9个月)发生迟发性脊髓病。3例肿瘤为转移性;3例为良性。转移瘤位于上胸段至中胸段脊柱,而良性肿瘤部分位于颈部区域。3例患者曾接受过放疗。
生成了靶区和关键结构的剂量体积直方图。分析临床和剂量学因素以寻找预测脊髓损伤的因素。虽然无法确定导致该并发症的具体剂量学因素,但发生脊髓病的患者中有一半接受的脊髓生物等效剂量超过8 Gy。
在本病例系列所采用的剂量方案下,放射外科治疗后发生迟发性脊髓病并不常见。脊髓的放射损伤发生在一系列剂量参数范围内,这使得无法确定导致该并发症的具体剂量学因素。主要是,生物等效剂量估计值无法用于定义脊髓对低分割剂量方案的耐受性。我们建议将脊髓等效剂量高于8 Gy的治疗体积限制在一定范围,因为一半的并发症发生在这个剂量水平以上。