Ginter E
Institute of Experimental and Clinical Medicine, Bratislava, Slovakia.
Bratisl Lek Listy. 2008;109(10):463-6.
Vegetarians form a non-homogenous group consisting of semivegetarians (plant food, dairy products, eggs and fish), lacto-ovo vegetarians (plant food, dairy products, eggs) and vegans (plant food only). According to pure vegetarian ideologists, people consuming vegetarian diet have better health and live longer than nonvegetarians, because persons consuming milk, dairy products, meat, eggs and fish are at health risk. In fact the most healthy people in Europe are inhabitants of Iceland, Switzerland and Scandinavia, consuming great amounts of food of animal origin. Meta-analysis of several prospective studies showed no significant differences in the mortality caused by colorectal, stomach, lung, prostate or breast cancers and stroke between vegetarians and "health-conscious" nonvegetarians. In vegetarians, a decrease of ischemic heart disease mortality was observed probably due to lower total serum cholesterol levels, lower prevalence of obesity and higher consumption of antioxidants. Very probably, an ample consumption of fruits and vegetables and not the exclusion of meat make vegetarians healthful. Now, the largest cohort study of diet and health on more than half million of persons, the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition (EPIC) study, will bring new data on the relationships between diet, lifestyle and environmental factors and the incidence of cancer, cardiovascular and other chronic diseases. Vegetarianism is a form of food restriction; and in our overfed society, food restriction is a plus unless it results in a nutritional deficiency (Fig. 1, Tab. 2, Ref. 18).
素食者构成了一个非同质群体,包括半素食者(食用植物性食物、乳制品、蛋类和鱼类)、蛋奶素食者(食用植物性食物、乳制品、蛋类)和纯素食者(仅食用植物性食物)。根据纯素食主义者的观点,食用素食的人比非素食者更健康、寿命更长,因为食用牛奶、乳制品、肉类、蛋类和鱼类的人存在健康风险。事实上,欧洲最健康的人群是冰岛、瑞士和斯堪的纳维亚半岛的居民,他们食用大量的动物性食物。对多项前瞻性研究的荟萃分析表明,素食者和“注重健康”的非素食者在结直肠癌、胃癌、肺癌、前列腺癌或乳腺癌以及中风导致的死亡率方面没有显著差异。在素食者中,缺血性心脏病死亡率有所下降,这可能是由于血清总胆固醇水平较低、肥胖患病率较低以及抗氧化剂摄入量较高。很可能是大量食用水果和蔬菜而非排除肉类使素食者保持健康。现在,一项针对超过50万人的关于饮食与健康的最大规模队列研究——欧洲癌症与营养前瞻性调查(EPIC)研究,将带来关于饮食、生活方式和环境因素与癌症、心血管疾病及其他慢性病发病率之间关系的新数据。素食主义是一种食物限制方式;在我们这个过度饮食的社会中,食物限制是一个优点,除非它导致营养缺乏(图1,表2,参考文献18)。