Hafslund Bjørg, Nortvedt Monica W
Institute of Radiography, Faculty of Health and Social Sciences, Bergen University College, Bergen, Norway.
Scand J Caring Sci. 2009 Sep;23(3):539-48. doi: 10.1111/j.1471-6712.2008.00634.x. Epub 2009 Jan 8.
The purpose of this literature review was to explore how women attending a national mammography screening programme reacted to the screening process on quality of life (QoL). The research question was what implications regarding true-negative results and false-positive results from mammography screening were found among women? Quality of life including life domains as psychological, physical and social was the theoretical reference in the study.
Guided by the concept of QoL on mammography screening a database search of Medline, Cinahl and Cochrane was carried out. Search terms such as QoL, anxiety and mammography have been used.
A review of studies between 1995 and 2007 showed that the implications regarding a negative result were less than those regarding false-positive one. It was found that women with negative results after mammography screening experience minor negative psychological consequences, and some women have even measured less anxiety following mammography than before because of the reassurance given by a clear negative result. False-positive result and recalls were a problem for many women. The process following recalls do affect women emotionally, decrease their wellbeing and QoL for weeks and even months.
Future research should be directed at measuring the short-term outcomes in representative populations for whom screening and prevention are indicated. This knowledge would be useful for the organisation of the mammography programmes and for communication with the general population, the women coming for screening and those who do not attend.
本综述的目的是探讨参加全国性乳房X线筛查项目的女性对筛查过程在生活质量(QoL)方面的反应。研究问题是在女性中发现了关于乳房X线筛查的真阴性结果和假阳性结果有哪些影响?包括心理、身体和社会等生活领域的生活质量是该研究的理论参考。
以乳房X线筛查生活质量的概念为指导,对Medline、Cinahl和Cochrane数据库进行了检索。使用了诸如生活质量、焦虑和乳房X线摄影等检索词。
对1995年至2007年的研究进行综述发现,关于阴性结果的影响小于假阳性结果。研究发现,乳房X线筛查结果为阴性的女性经历的负面心理影响较小,而且由于明确的阴性结果带来的安心,一些女性在乳房X线摄影后测量的焦虑甚至比之前还少。假阳性结果和召回对许多女性来说是个问题。召回后的过程确实会在情感上影响女性,降低她们的幸福感和生活质量长达数周甚至数月。
未来的研究应针对对有筛查和预防需求的代表性人群测量短期结果。这些知识将有助于乳房X线筛查项目的组织以及与普通人群、前来筛查的女性和未参加筛查的女性进行沟通。