McNulty John A, Hoyt Amy, Gruener Gregory, Chandrasekhar Arcot, Espiritu Baltazar, Price Ron, Naheedy Ross
Department of Cell Biology, Neurobiology and Anatomy, Stritch School of Medicine, Loyola University Chicago, Maywood, IL, USA.
BMC Med Educ. 2009 Jan 27;9:6. doi: 10.1186/1472-6920-9-6.
Increasing numbers of medical schools are providing videos of lectures to their students. This study sought to analyze utilization of lecture videos by medical students in their basic science courses and to determine if student utilization was associated with performance on exams.
Streaming videos of lectures (n = 149) to first year and second year medical students (n = 284) were made available through a password-protected server. Server logs were analyzed over a 10-week period for both classes. For each lecture, the logs recorded time and location from which students accessed the file. A survey was administered at the end of the courses to obtain additional information about student use of the videos.
There was a wide disparity in the level of use of lecture videos by medical students with the majority of students accessing the lecture videos sparingly (60% of the students viewed less than 10% of the available videos. The anonymous student survey revealed that students tended to view the videos by themselves from home during weekends and prior to exams. Students who accessed lecture videos more frequently had significantly (p < 0.002) lower exam scores.
We conclude that videos of lectures are used by relatively few medical students and that individual use of videos is associated with the degree to which students are having difficulty with the subject matter.
越来越多的医学院校为学生提供讲座视频。本研究旨在分析医学生在基础科学课程中对讲座视频的利用情况,并确定学生的利用情况是否与考试成绩相关。
通过一个受密码保护的服务器向一年级和二年级医学生(n = 284)提供讲座视频流(n = 149)。在为期10周的时间里对两个班级的服务器日志进行分析。对于每一次讲座,日志记录了学生访问文件的时间和地点。在课程结束时进行了一项调查,以获取有关学生使用视频的更多信息。
医学生对讲座视频的使用水平存在很大差异,大多数学生很少访问讲座视频(60%的学生观看的视频不到可用视频的10%)。匿名学生调查显示,学生倾向于在周末和考试前在家中独自观看视频。更频繁访问讲座视频的学生考试成绩显著较低(p < 0.002)。
我们得出结论,相对较少的医学生使用讲座视频,而且学生个人对视频的使用与学生在学科内容上遇到困难的程度相关。