Jia Mary S, Rao Raj R, Elsaadany Mostafa
Department of Biomedical Engineering, University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, USA.
J Biol Eng. 2023 Mar 30;17(1):26. doi: 10.1186/s13036-023-00339-7.
Recent advancements in additive manufacturing have made 3D design a desirable skill in combating the historically slow development of biomedical products. Due to the broad applicability of additive manufacturing to biomedical engineering, 3D design and 3D printing are attractive educational tools for biomedical engineering students. However, due to the multidisciplinary nature of biomedical engineering, finding a suitable spot in the curriculum to teach students basic and application-based skills for 3D manufacturing is difficult. Furthermore, prior training in fundamental 3D design skills may be needed to support the use of application-based supplementary content.
We designed a SolidWorks Simulations toolkit to complement a sophomore (2nd-year)-level Biomechanics course and distributed this assignment to students with and without prior training in 3D design delivered in an introductory biomedical engineering course. Using short videos, example-based problem solving, and step-by-step tutorials, students completed this as an extra-credit assignment and completed a survey gauging student opinion on SolidWorks and 3D design, confidence in each target skill, and the effectiveness of assignment delivery. The compilation of survey responses suggests that the assignment effectively increased positive responses in student opinion on interest in and likeliness to use SolidWorks in both groups. However, confidence in the target assignment skills was higher in the trained group and fewer problems occurred in operating SolidWorks for trained students. Further, analyzing the distribution of student grades with respect to survey responses suggests that responses had no relationship with initial class grade.
These data collectively indicate that prior training provided to the students had a positive impact on the effectiveness of the assignment although increases in student opinion on the utility of 3D design were observed in both trained and untrained students. Our work has generated and identified a useful educational supplement to enrich existing biomedical engineering course materials with practical skills.
增材制造技术的最新进展使三维(3D)设计成为应对生物医学产品开发长期以来进展缓慢问题的一项理想技能。由于增材制造在生物医学工程领域具有广泛的适用性,3D设计和3D打印对于生物医学工程专业的学生来说是颇具吸引力的教育工具。然而,由于生物医学工程具有多学科性质,在课程中找到一个合适的位置来教授学生3D制造的基础技能和应用技能并非易事。此外,可能需要先进行基础3D设计技能培训,以支持基于应用的补充内容的使用。
我们设计了一个SolidWorks模拟工具包,以补充大学二年级水平的生物力学课程,并将此作业分发给在生物医学工程入门课程中接受过或未接受过3D设计先修培训的学生。通过短视频、基于示例的问题解决方法和逐步教程,学生们将此作为一项额外加分作业完成,并完成了一项调查,以衡量学生对SolidWorks和3D设计的看法、对每项目标技能的信心以及作业交付的有效性。调查反馈的汇总表明,该作业有效地提高了两组学生对使用SolidWorks的兴趣和可能性的积极反馈。然而,接受过培训的组对目标作业技能的信心更高,并且接受过培训的学生在操作SolidWorks时出现的问题更少。此外,分析学生成绩分布与调查反馈之间的关系表明,反馈与初始课程成绩无关。
这些数据共同表明,尽管在接受过培训和未接受过培训的学生中都观察到学生对3D设计实用性的看法有所提高,但提前为学生提供的培训对作业的有效性产生了积极影响。我们的工作已经产生并确定了一种有用的教育补充材料,以用实践技能丰富现有的生物医学工程课程材料。