Mas Garriga Xavier, Navarro Gilo Montserrat, Vázquez Morocho Judit, Delso Gafarot Cristina, Mahfouz Castejón Tarek, Almeda Ortega Jesús
Institut Català de la Salut, L'Hospitalet de Llobregat, Barcelona, España.
Aten Primaria. 2009 Jan;41(1):9-15. doi: 10.1016/j.aprim.2008.05.006. Epub 2008 Dec 19.
To find out the prevalence and causes of "difficult encounters" (DE) in Primary Care clinics from the perspective of the patients and doctors, and to whom the responsibility and concordance of the DE (CDE) between doctors and patients is attributed.
Cross-sectional, descriptive.
Urban health centre.
Four doctors, their 4 residents and patients who went to their clinics (March-May 2007). The doctors selected the DE with qualitative criteria, the patients by means of a non-validated ad hoc questionnaire.
sex and age of the patients, defined DE, causes and responsibility of the DE, changes in doctor due to unease and a perception of a "difficult professional" (DP) by the patient.
There were 415 visits; 352 questionnaires (85% participation); 212 (60.2%) women, mean age (SD) 54.7 (18.2) years. DE prevalence: 8.5% according to doctors (95% CI, 5.8-11.9) (main cause: idiosyncrasy of the patient), the cause of unease always being attributed to the patient; 3.1% according to the patients (95% CI, 1.6-5.5) (main cause: lack of empathy by the doctor), the unease being attributed to the doctor in 81% of cases. CDE insignificant (kappa=0.003). Only 15 patients (4.3%) felt uncomfortable in a visit in the last year; 18 (5.1%) considered a change of doctor due to unease (95% CI, 3.1-8); 53 (15.1%) had changed at some point for this reason (95% CI, 11.3-18.8) and 11 (3.1%) considered their doctor to be DP (95% CI, 1.6-5.5).
The prevalence of DE in our clinics is similar to that reported in other studies, but lower than expected for the patients, with an insignificant CDE. Doctors and patients usually attribute the responsibility of the DE to the other party. Few patients consider their doctor to be a DP.
从患者和医生的角度找出基层医疗诊所中“诊疗困难”(DE)的患病率及原因,以及医患之间诊疗困难的责任归属与一致性(CDE)。
横断面描述性研究。
城市健康中心。
4名医生、他们的4名住院医师以及前往其诊所就诊的患者(2007年3月至5月)。医生依据定性标准选取DE病例,患者通过一份未经验证的特设问卷进行反馈。
患者的性别和年龄、定义的DE、DE的原因及责任归属、因不安导致的医生更换情况以及患者对“难相处的医生”(DP)的认知。
共415次就诊;352份问卷(参与率85%);212名女性(60.2%),平均年龄(标准差)54.7(18.2)岁。医生报告的DE患病率为8.5%(95%置信区间,5.8 - 11.9)(主要原因:患者特质),不安的原因总是归咎于患者;患者报告的患病率为3.1%(95%置信区间,1.6 - 5.5)(主要原因:医生缺乏同理心),81%的情况下不安归咎于医生。CDE无统计学意义(kappa = 0.003)。去年仅有15名患者(4.3%)在就诊时感到不适;18名患者(5.1%)因不安考虑更换医生(95%置信区间,3.1 - 8);53名患者(15.1%)曾因此更换过医生(95%置信区间,11.3 - 18.8),11名患者(3.1%)认为他们的医生是难相处的医生(95%置信区间,1.6 - 5.5)。
我们诊所中DE的患病率与其他研究报告的相似,但低于患者预期,CDE无统计学意义。医生和患者通常将DE的责任归咎于对方。很少有患者认为他们的医生是难相处的医生。