Fenton Joshua J, Reid Robert J, Baldwin Laura-Mae, Elmore Joann G, Buist Diana S M, Franks Peter
Department of Family and Community Medicine and Center for Healthcare Policy and Research, University of California Davis, Sacramento, CA 95817, USA.
Cancer Epidemiol Biomarkers Prev. 2009 Feb;18(2):640-5. doi: 10.1158/1055-9965.EPI-08-0765. Epub 2009 Feb 3.
Colorectal cancer (CRC) screening is commonly initiated during primary care visits. Thus, at the population level, limited primary care attendance may constitute a substantial barrier to CRC screening uptake. Within a defined population, we quantified the percent of CRC screening underuse that is potentially explained by low use of primary care visits.
Among 48,712 adults ages 50 to 78 years eligible for CRC screening within a Washington state health plan, we estimated the degree to which a lack of CRC screening in 2002 to 2003 (fecal occult blood testing, sigmoidoscopy, or colonoscopy) was attributable to low primary care use, expressed as the population attributable risk percent (PAR%) associated with 0 to 3 primary care visits during the 2-year period.
In analyses adjusted for age, comorbidity, nonprimary care visit use, and prior preventive service use, low primary care use in 2002 to 2003 was strongly associated with a lack of CRC screening among both women and men. However, a majority of unscreened women and men had > or =4 primary care visits. Thus, whether low primary care use was defined as 0, 0 to 1, 0 to 2, or 0 to 3 primary care visits, the PAR% associated with low primary care use was large in neither women (range, 3.0-6.8%) nor men (range: 5.6-11.5%).
Health plan outreach efforts to encourage primary care attendance would be unlikely to substantially increase population uptake of CRC screening. In similar settings, resources might be more fruitfully devoted to the optimization of screening delivery during primary care visits that patients already attend.
结直肠癌(CRC)筛查通常在初级保健就诊期间启动。因此,在人群层面,初级保健就诊率有限可能构成CRC筛查普及的重大障碍。在特定人群中,我们量化了因初级保健就诊使用率低而可能导致的CRC筛查未充分利用的百分比。
在华盛顿州一项健康计划中,48712名年龄在50至78岁之间符合CRC筛查条件的成年人中,我们估计了2002年至2003年期间缺乏CRC筛查(粪便潜血试验、乙状结肠镜检查或结肠镜检查)可归因于初级保健利用率低的程度,以2年期间0至3次初级保健就诊的人群归因风险百分比(PAR%)表示。
在对年龄、合并症、非初级保健就诊使用情况和既往预防服务使用情况进行调整的分析中,2002年至2003年初级保健利用率低与男性和女性缺乏CRC筛查密切相关。然而,大多数未接受筛查的女性和男性有≥4次初级保健就诊。因此,无论初级保健利用率低是定义为0次、0至1次、0至2次还是0至3次初级保健就诊,与初级保健利用率低相关的PAR%在女性(范围:3.0 - 6.8%)和男性(范围:5.6 - 11.5%)中都不大。
健康计划为鼓励初级保健就诊所做的外展努力不太可能大幅提高人群对CRC筛查的接受率。在类似情况下,资源可能更有效地用于优化患者已经就诊的初级保健就诊期间的筛查服务。